← Back to The HUT

July 1970 · Vol. 4 No. 9

July 1970 Magazine (Vol. 4 No. 9)

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 32 pages

July 1970 Magazine (Vol. 4 No. 9)

Captured text — scan page 22

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

Action Continues on B.W.C.A.

An important victory for conservationists in the Isaac Walton
League's suit to prevent mineral drilling in the Boundary Waters
Canoe Area was won in early June. U.S. District Judge Philip
Neville denied the federal government's attempt to have itself
dismissed as a codefendent. During the hearings on this part of
the suit, Nelson Grubbe, the government's representative, argued
that the league couldn't sue because it had no personal stake in
the outcome and, under the doctrine of sovereign immunity, the
federal government. could not be sued without its consent.

Judge Neville denied this last point on the basis of a March 5
U.S. Supreme Court decision relaxing the standards for groups see
seeking to use the government. That decision reversed an earlier
ruling by Judge Neville himself. Raymond Haik, lawyer for the
Walton League noted that the league had sold thousands of acres of
BWCA land to the government on the assumption that it would remain
a wilderness. He also contended that federal officials are violat-~
ing their own regulations by permitting mineral explorations bec-
ause federal zoning laws prohibit the exercise of mineral rights
in the BWCA. Judge Neville agreed and noted that the league "is
not a 'johnny-come-lately' or an ad-hoc organization and its inter-
est in the wilderness movement is continuing, basic and deep".

Thus the effect of this ruling will be to keep Secretary of
Agriculture, Clifford Hardin, Chief of the U.S. Forest Service,
Edward Cliff, and Supervisor of the Superior National Forest,
Craig Rupp as defendents in the suit. The other defendants are
George St. Clair, Thomas Yawkey and the State of Minnesota.

20

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.