August 1971 · Vol. 5 No. 9
August 1971 Magazine (Vol. 5 No. 9)
Magazine · 20 pages
Search this issue
For the full-resolution original, use Open PDF above. Your browser handles PDF zoom and navigation.
Searchable text for scan page 6
Half a Million Dollars Raised boat, or exposure to cold water when wearing a
- lifejacket. Even more significant is the total of
by Canoe Tax Bill — Why? 100,000 canoeists in the State (DNR estimate).
Continuing a series of analyses Does the tragedy of eight thousandths of one
by Joe Conrad percent (0.008%) require a Jaw to regulate the
In the next three years $500,000 of Minne- activities of the other 99.992%? Only eight out
sota canoe-owners license fees will go into the Of 100,000 seems to be a remarkable safety
state treasury. None of this is dedicated to ecord. Certainly this provision is well-meaning
benefit canoeists directly. Approximately and may save a few lives. I believe, however,
$140,000 will simply go down the rathole of that a law should respond to a definite need.
the bureaucracy needed to administer the law. Canocists have, it seems a remarkable safety
Why is this law necessary? Surely canoes must record and should be judged capable, asa class,
be a public nuisance or a danger to innocent Of regulating their own safety requirements
lives to warrant such regulation. without the need of special laws.)
Our Minnesota Department of Natural Re- 5. Again concerning lifejackets: “Only
sources (DNR), formerly the Conservation De- Coast Guard-approved life preservers should be
partment, pushed this bill along through the legal, otherwise the DNR would have to test
legislature. The DNR spokesman at legislative nonapproved devices.” (With the revenue from
hearings was Bill Severson, who also spoke at 100,000 canoe licenses a testing program
our May 19 MCA meeting. The following are should be a snap. There are a number of jackets
quotations from Mr. Severson either made at not approved by the Coast Guard which are
hearings or at meetings with canoeists. My safe for canoeing. They are comfortable and
comments are in parentheses. hence much more likely to be worn than
1. “Over one-half of all canoes nowadays kneeled on, sat on, or tied to the canoe.)
are motorized anyway.”’ (Absolutely no factual 6. “‘Canoeists are the first to scream when a
basis for such a statement.) powerboat swamps them, yet are not willing to
2. “Canoeists should pay the costs of sher- pay for boating law enforcement.” (An incred-
iffs’ search and rescue operations.” (Fair ible statement. Tax the offenders, not the
enough, but perhaps they should only pay in victims.) ;
direct proportion to the number of canoe- 7. “Funds are needed to buy more public
caused deaths and injuries and sheriffs’ ex- access to Minnesota waters.” (No doubt true —
penses incurred as compared to those deaths, put will canoeists benefit? We don’t need large,
injuries and expenses caused by motorboats. No expensive, paved ramps. We do need acreage on
data was presented which made any compari- rivers for parking our cars and camping. We do
sons. Mr. Severson gave the impression that need an enlarged BWCA. For this we are willing
county sheriffs were going broke looking for to pay for a license, but are the license funds
canoe victims.) dedicated to this? No. In fact the money goes
3. “Canoeists use state parks and don’t pay into the general State treasury. We can only
their share of fees.” (How many canoes do you hope that the DNR would try to pry it out
see on cars without Minnesota park stickers on again for the benefit of canoeists.)
them? To avoid paying a daily park visitor fee, 8. “Licensing will deter theft.” (This is one
how many canoeists bother to portage instead of the hoariest arguments of all. Everyone
of drive their boats through a state park to the knows that licensing does not deter theft of,
highway? How many canoeists camp in state gay, bicycles. They are stolen in broad daylight
parks without paying overnight camping fees?) and never traced. Canoes are not much dif-
4. Concerning required lifejackets or ferent. A license would help in those rare cases
cushions: “Eight people drowned in canoe jn which a thief abandons the boat after using it
accidents last year, and 20 more may drown once. A much more effective measure would be
over the next two years if we don’t require {9 require all canoes sold in Minnesota to have a
lifejackets.” (Certainly any drowning is a trag- serial number engraved in the hull.)
edy. The MCA is not against lifejackets or water 9. ‘Minnesota will lose $100,000 to
safety. We publish articles on safety and strong- $500,000 in federal aid if this licensing bill
ly urge that lifejackets be worn by non- doesn’t pass.” (This was never explained fully
swimmers at all times and by othersin rapids or at any time and is a vague reference to federal
on very cold waters. I believe that education is legislation which is proposed but not yet law. It
much more effective than regulation. Con- is the type of legislation arising from some
cerning the eight drownings, how many were agency in Washington, D. C., which decides that
due primarily to absence of a lifejacket? No all state boating laws should be uniform. They
data was presented to separate drownings draw up a model uniform code, then get federal
caused by physical illness (e.g., epileptic legislation which will reward the states for
seizure, heart attack), collision with a power- passing this code into law. The reward in this
2 HUT! — AUGUST 1971
Article contents & approved summaries (0)
No article summaries are available for this view.