Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.
This shows the complete scan page, including any other material on it.
ASK MCA!!!
HAVE QUESTIONS ABOUT WHERE TO GO, WHAT TO PACK,
BUILDING, PADDLING, OR STAYING AFLOAT? Send them to: Ask MCA,
Minnesota Canoe Association, Box 14207 University Station, Minneapolis,
MN 55414.
The two weeks between the announcement of our new Ask MCA
feature in the January HUT! and the February publication deadline did not
leave time for a flood of questions, but we did get one. It comes from a
Trivial Pursuit player who was confused by this question in the Science &
Nature category of the Genus edition.
Q: What bank lies to the left of a canoeist paddling upstream, the left
or the right?
A: It's the right, as the Trivial Pursuit people accurately state. Why?
By convention, right and left on a river correspond to the right and left of a
person facing downstream.
We asked several professional geographers where this convention
originated, but none of them knew. They only knew that it is the
convention, and that it is apparently universal (some geographic desig-
nations, such as the numbering of tributaries, vary from country to country).
We suspect that this convention originated not with geographers, but
rather with canoeists, who long ago figured out that paddling upstream is
perverse. Paddling downstream is a more natural form of navigation, hence
the downstream facing left/right convention. Avoid paddling upstream and
you'll avoid confusion.
However, canoe racing—which some may also consider to be an
unnatural act—requires paddlers to face upstream a good portion of the
time. If a racer wants to call his partners attention to, let's say a beaver
lodge, on the river's left bank, what does he say? Look to your right? Look
over on the left bank? Look to starboard? Look over there?
While on the river, MCA racers inform us, they refer to their own right
and their own left, even when paddling upstream. So in this case, an
upstream paddler would say, "Look at that beaver lodge over to the right."
But, when discussing the trip afterwards, they follow the downstream facing
left/right convention. That means they refer to the river in the opposite
way they actually saw it: "Remember that beaver lodge on the left bank?"
Even a confirmed cruiser/drifter who avoids upstream paddling like the
plague could conceivably encounter some left bank/right bank confusion.
Say you are canoeing downstream, but want to put in at a campsight you've
been told is just fifty yards upstream on a tributary that empties into the
river you're cruising. The eampsight, you've been told, is on the left bank.
Remember to look to your right as you paddle those fifty yards. Otherwise,
you might end up paddling a lot farther upstream than you care to before
seeing any campsite. — David Stamps
Since its formation 10,000 years ago, St. Anthony Falls has retreated eight
miles upstream on the Mississippi from the location of Fort Snelling to the
falls' present location, an average rate of perhaps four feet per year,
alternately eroding the soft St. Peter sandstone and causing the hard
Platteville limestone to break off, leaving behind a deep scenic gorge
through the center of the present metropolitan area.
Streams and Rivers of Minnesota —
Waters.
Tom Water HUT! 27