Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.
GRINDING CLIFF'S AXE
In the last two issues of HUT! readers have been treated to a couple of
pieces by Cliff Jacobson extolling the virtues of hand axes, bright colored
camping gear, and other paraphernalia from the history of camping manuals.
One thing is for sure, after reading those articles I am convinced that Cliff
is opinionated! However, in my opinion he misrepresents the issues, offers
feeble excuses for his opinions, and does an injustice to the new BWCAW
User Education Program. The majority of the group working on the BWCAW
User Education Program is proposing that the use of hand axes and brightly
eolored camping gear be discouraged. Here's why.
Visitor use of the BWCAW has skyrocketed in the last 20 years. The
sheer numbers of visitors cause significant environmental deterioration to
the resource, and the campsites and portages show the signs of overuse and
abuse. There is no question but that the improper use of hand axes is a
major source of vandalism and damage to the wilderness. Virtually all
campsites on regularly used routes show the sears of idiots who wantonly
hack away at trees that are hundreds of years old.
The percentage of users who intentionally vandalize the BWCA, when
combined with those who unintentionally damage this resource, is enough to
produce pervasive and long-lasting effects. While it can be argued that
people—not hand axes—destroy wilderness, there's no question but that
without an axe, hackers are reduced to their bare hands. The wilderness is
much more likely to survive this menace.
Cliff's justifications for bringing a hand axe are hard to swallow. Hand
axes are about as useful on a wilderness canoe trip as your grandmother's
girdle—any competent outdoorsperson will tell you that. Cliff's characteri-
zations of those who wish to discourage axe use as "desk-bound environmen-
talists" is unfair and unfounded. Here are the facts.
If you are dependent upon a hand axe to start a fire in the wilderness,
you do not belong in the woods. I've been on over 50 extended BWCAW and
Ontario canoe trips (most with physically disabled persons), plus a couple of
trips to the Yukon, the Wind River Range, and one to the Andes in Peru. I've
never brought an axe, I've always been able to start a fire, and my
experience is hardly unique. Virtually every other major outdoor program
that I know of (including Outward Bound, the YMCA's, the National Outdoor
Leadership School, and dozens of others) have policies discouraging the use
of axes.
If you are competent you should always know where to find dry tinder.
If you understand the basic principles of fire starting—fuel, oxygen, and
heat—there's no reason why you shouldn't be able to start a fire, even after
a week-long rain. In a pinch, a candle or fire-ribbon will get anything
started. Sorry Cliff, but an axe simply isn't necessary.
In the April issue of HUT! Cliff suggests that a hand axe is a vital tool
for pounding tent stakes—phooey! The heel of your boot or a good rock work
equally well. In the second article Cliff paints the scenario of the camper in
' a program that only brings jeans, proceeds to get them wet, and is dependent
upon a hand axe to get a fire started for survival. Phooey again! Any
competent outdoor leader would never let a kid get away with just bringing
-jeans in the first place—that's irresponsible. Wool clothes and good rain
suits are essential on any trip to the BWCAW.
I haven't even mentioned the facts that hand axes are heavy and
account for many serious accidents in the wilderness. Those are the facts,
just ask the Forest Service for the numbers.
HUT! 34