Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.
The issue of brightly colored camping gear is minor, but I agree that
earth tones are nicer. All one has to do is go to a popular BWCAW lake in
- July or August to see the hillsides splashed with every color of tent in the
rainbow. Bright colors do no long-lasting damage to the wilderness.
However, I will say that if you are dependent on your blazing orange tent to
guide you back to your campsite, you're in big trouble!
It was unfair of Cliff to characterize the people working on the
BWCAW User Education Program as incompetent. This effort enjoys broad
support from many outdoor educators who are dedicated, competent, and
have a concern for our natural resources. This effort should never be
dismissed as a group of elitists who are arbitrarily trying to impose
restraints on wilderness users.
I also think it was irresponsible to tacitly suggest disregarding laws you
don't agree with, as he did in the second article. Some people disagree with
the restrictions on motorboats and snowmobiles in the BWCAW, and for that
matter with the ban on cans and bottles. Should these laws simply be
disregarded if we disagree with them? I hope not. There is no law banning
the use of hand axes in the BWCAS. Hopefully, there will never be one.
Before I finish let me say that I respect Cliff Jacobson and I know he is
a dedicated outdoor educator who shares the goal of protecting our natural
resources. I ask him, and you, to consider the following:
When we talk of an environmental ethic, there is an implied under-
standing that our natural resources are finite. The BWCAW is in fact a tiny
remnant of the virgin forests that dominated Minnesota a mere 120 years
ago. This remnant is a priceless part of our heritage that must be
protected—NOT JUST FOR TOMORROW BUT FOR ALL TIME. At current
usage, the BWCAW doesn't have time right now to properly recouperate
from its annual summer thrashing. What will the BWCAW look like in 2020,
or 2285, or for that matter 5985? The BWCAW has existed since the last ice
age in roughly its present form. What will Ogishkemuncie Lake look like in
5,000 years? I shudder to think about it.
The major emphasis of the BWCAW User Education Program is
environmental awareness to reduce the problem of user impact on the
resource. It is a far sighted effort to head off problems and reduce the need
for regulations such as the can and bottle laws. Our alternatives are to put
a tight limit on BWCAW use through use permit restrictions (the mechanism
for this exists today), accept a diminished resource, or educate people on
camping practices that minimize their impact on the environment. The
Forest Service has wisely chosen the option of education over regulation,
and they are asking for our help in pulling it off.
Everyone agrees that the improper use of the hand axe is a major
factor in camper abuse of the wilderness. Since it's basically an unnecessary
tool, let's discourage it in the BWCAW-—just as we've discouraged the use of
bough beds, guns, and soaping up in the lakes. What do you think, Cliff?
Would you be willing to risk taking a trip without your hand axe or your
orange tent? I know several hundred outdoor people who would gladly show
you how. — Greg Lais
(Ed. note: Greg Lais is the director of Wilderness Inquiry II, a non-profit,
Minneapolis-based program that conducts wilderness canoe and dogsled trips
for integrated.groups of physically disabled and non-disabled persons.)
HUT! — 35