← Back to The HUT

May 1985 · Vol. 21 No. 5

May 1985 Magazine (Vol. 21 No. 5)

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 40 pages

May 1985 Magazine (Vol. 21 No. 5)

Captured text — scan page 18

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

A MATTER OF OPINION

As you know, Al Gustaveson and I have been working closely with the
forest service to develop a wilderness ethics curriculum that will help solve
the abuses in the BWCA. If you were at the March 9 event at Brooklyn
Center, you know how important this issue is. Dozens of people from the far
corners of the state are working diligently and freely giving their time to
this endeavor. For the sake of our wilderness areas, let's hope it pays off.

While I actively support the forest service goals in this respect, I am
not in complete agreement with their philosophy. My nineteen years as an
educator has taught me that teaching is ineffective if students can't relate
to the outeome—if there are no viable alternatives. For example, the
current ban on bottles and cans works only because freeze-dried/dehydrated
products can be substituted for the "real thing." If dried foods didn't exist,
the bottle/ean ban wouldn't work, no matter how loudly we proclaimed its
value. After all, people have to eat!

Similarly, they also have (or rather "want") to make fires, be it for
warmth, cooking, or aesthetics. It is our job to show them how to do this
without damaging the environment. Last month I baited you with my article
on the hand-axe. If you've spent time in the back country, you'll agree it is a
very important tool for making fire when the woods are soaked from weeks
of rain. Sure, you can coax a blaze from a handful of squaw wood with
patience and fire-ribbon, but try to make it grow to warming proportions
without using split wood. Everyone knows that sawn logs that are soaking
wet won't burn unless they're split—the reason why a hand-axe or splitting
tool is so important in really foul weather.

Yeah, but who needs it? you say. After all, there is the stove! And
don't forget the tent and dry sleeping bags. Fires are passé. We can do
without 'em.

Baloney!

Aesthetics and joy aside, consider this: You're tripping with a group of
teenagers in early June. For a full week it has rained and rained and rained.
At night, the wind drops but the rain continues. And the day begins with
more rain which subsides to penetrating droplets of fog by mid-afternoon.
You're the trip leader. You've got wool and polypropylene and rain gear that
works. The kids have blue jeans and cast-offs and cheapie rain suits. You've
got sense enough to keep your gear dry; the kids don't. They leave tent
doors open and weather flaps unzipped in driving rain; they bring wet boots
and gear into their tents and/or leave dry clothes outside. They crowd four
or more to a tent so there's no way to escape sidewall condensation or a
loealized leak in the tent floor. Kids are kids and kids get wet. You're the
leader and it's your job to dry them out. Just try doing that with the heat of
your Coleman Peak I!

It is the policy of the forest service to actively discourage the uses of
axes (big ones or little ones) in the back country. The feds say that the
major cause of abuse centers around axe-hacked trees. I believe it. I've
seen enough fire grates choked shut with green boughs and logs that would
not burn to know they're right. But I also know that those boughs are mostly
a frustrated way of saying, "Help! I don't know how to make a fire and am
simply doing what I think is best." Eliminate the axe and desperate campers
will simply cut boughs with their pocket knife. Or they'll saw them off. Or
break them off. Man is very creative when it comes to destroying things.

Really now, wouldn't it be better to simply educate these folks in the
"proper way" to use these woods tools? The proper way to make a fire? I
laid it all out for you last month. Think about it.

aiausie iV

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.