January 1987 · Vol. 23 No. 1
January 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 1)
Magazine · 36 pages
Search this issue
January 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 1)
Captured text — scan page 28
Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.
JACOBSON/BROWN -- WHO IS RIGHT?
I would like to take the opportunity of adding my two cents worth
to the Jacobson/Brown “best canoe" controversy. Cliff feels that a
person should choose a “worst case canoe." I cannot agree with this.
Instead of choosing a bomb-proof barge, try improving your skills so
that you can handle the finer-lined canoe. While leaning towards Bob
Brown's philosopy, I don't go quite to the extremes that he does. I
want the "two-moose" hauler, but it has to be easy to paddle.
Apparently not an easy combination to find.
We started canoeing in a seventeen foot, 85 pound, aluminum beast
which was chosen by the scientific method--"We have a Ward's credit
card, let's buy a canoe there." After paddling it for seven years we
decided to upgrade to a WENONAH Sundowner. Canoeing became more fun.
No, the pop wasn't any colder, but the paddling was easier. We kept
the tin beast for the rough work--Minnehaha Creek; whitewater;
loaning out.
Now we are fortunate enough to have five canoes: WENONAH
Sundowner, 18' WENONAH Jensen, 17' WENONAH Jensen, Blue Hole OCA, and
Old Town Camper. (The Ward's beast was sold.) Yes, this is a lot of
canoes. Yes, you have to be a little crazy to own that many. Yes,
we do have a chunk of money tied up in them. And, yes we do take our
canoeing very seriously.
Which one is best? Which one is the "all around canoe?" If I
had to choose just one, which one would it be? Let me take the
questions in order:
None of them is the "best." Best for what? I wouldn't want to
take any of the WENONAH canoes through Banning Rapids on the Kettle.
Being fiberglass boats that are long and sleek with no rocker they
just are a poor choice. The 01d Town is too shallow to make it. The
only choice would be the Royalex Blue Hole. It was designed as a
whitewater play boat. How about the Boundary Waters? The clear
choice here would be the Sundowner. Eighteen feet of fast, easy
tracking, load hauler. Day tripping? Either of the Jensens. Float
fishing down a quiet river? The wide, short (16') Old Town. The Old
Town also shines when it comes to narrow, twisty streams like
Minnehaha Creek. Being made of Royalex, it also can take the abuse
that the Creek can dish out.
None of them is the "all around canoe." The Sundowner comes
closest. We have had it through Class II rapids with a good load, on
fast day trips, paddled high waves with a huge load.
To cut back to one would be painful. I would have to go with the
Sundowner. On those occasions when it would not be appropriate, I
would rent or borrow a different craft.
Longer is better. It is easier to make a long canoe turn than to
try to make a short, rockered canoe track. Think about it: most of
the time you are going in a relatively straight line. Fighting the
short canoe all day will wear out the toughest paddler. Last month I
recommended taking the MCA classes. By using the techniques taught
in the Efficient Paddling Class, you can handle the longer canoes.
The ultimate choice is yours. Try other canoes every chance you
get. Maybe you will want to change. Maybe not. I work with a man
who thinks his Coleman is great. He floats down the river, fishing
and rarely touching a paddle. When he hits the shallows, he just
drags the craft over the rocks. For him, I would recommend no other
canoe.
Above all, the idea is enjoyment. Don't worry if you don't have
the latest hi-tech canoe. If you are having a good time in your
Brand-X canoe that isn't bomb proof or sleek and lean, more power to
you. doin a cruise that matches your skill and equipment level. If
anybody is so insensitive as to comment about your canoe, tell them
24 HUT!
Article contents & approved summaries (0)
No article summaries are available for this view.