July 1987 · Vol. 23 No. 7
July 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 7)
Magazine · 40 pages
Search this issue
July 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 7)
Captured text — scan page 13
Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.
As we neared Highway 35, we saw an immature eagle, then an adult
one. Within a mile between the highway and the Burlington Northern
tracks, we lost count of the Eagles we saw, really a climax to the
Chippewa.
The last three miles were on the Mississippi, back on my river.
With Lake Pepin behind and Wabasha ahead, we met many motor boats, it
was a real change in pace bouncing over their waves.
All in all, we had an excellent trip. The Lower Chippewa is
really worth doing. If you really must sleep on the ground, you'll
find plenty of great spots to camp. As long as I have friends like
Martin Van, I'11 choose a bed every time.--Bob Brown
CALLING IT A ROSE DON'T MAKE IT SMELL LIKE ONE
The first thing I would like to make clear is that this is NOT
editorial comment and I do not _ speak for the MCA but for myself
alone. That out of the way, here are some observations:
I just received the latest issue of CANOE magazine. (August
1987). Starting on page 36 is a "Water Test" of “Day trippers." The
subtitle of the article is "All Around Canoes for Family or Fun."
One of the canoes reviewed is the Wenonah Sundowner. As many of you
know, I have owned a Sundowner for six years and recommend it highly.
I was interested to see what the article said as not too long ago the
same magazine had reviewed the Sundowner in a different perspective.
The first discordant note I encountered was "moderate bow rocker."
What bow rocker? The Sundowner has zero rocker. The next thing was
“problems for our tall, long legged paddlers." What was wrong with
this reviewer? I've seen six-foot-plus paddlers in the bow of a
Sundowner having no problems at all.
When I got to their "Stats at a Glance" table, all was suddenly
made clear, In the length column, the Sundowner was 16' 6". Aha!!
No wonder the review did not make a whole lot of sense to me. Now I
understand! Why didn't the reviewer mention that this was the “baby
brother" to the REAL Sundowner? The canoe in question is the old
Wenonah Echo. This canoe is what Wenonah is now calling the 16' 6”
Sundowner,
Wenonah has seen fit to call this canoe a Sundowner “because its
design and usage are very much the same as our 18° Sundowner." To
this I say, "Hogwash!" I do not feel that these canoes are in the
same league for design or usage. The Sundowner is for people who
take their canoeing very seriously, the Echo is for people who need
less or can afford less of a canoe.
The Wenonah catalog continues with, "....you'll see that this
hull and its longer brother have very similar dimensions and much the
same shape. Of course, this one is 18" shorter giving it greater
maneuverability but somewhat Jess capacity and straight line
efficency." Wenonah goes on to say that the canoe does not have the
capabilities of the 18° Sundowner for wind-driven lakes or long
distance tripping.
I have paddled both of these canoes. My 18° Sundowner has seen
greatly varied waters. From calm flatwater on lakes to two-foot
wind-driven rollers to Class III rapids. It has carried loads
ranging from two persons with water bottles and spare paddles to a
crew totaling 300 pounds plus more than that in gear. I have paddled
hundreds of miles in this canoe and know its capabilities extremely
well.
In the past I have suggested the Wenonah Echo to some people and
will continue to do so for those who will benefit from this canoe. I
never recommend any canoe I have not paddled. I have not had the
chance to wring out the Wenonah Echo to the same degree as the
CALL IT A ROSE--CONTINUED ON PAGE 14
July 1987-HUT! 13
Article contents & approved summaries (0)
No article summaries are available for this view.