October 1987 · Vol. 23 No. 10
October 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 10)
Magazine · 32 pages
Search this issue
For the full-resolution original, use Open PDF above. Your browser handles PDF zoom and navigation.
Searchable text for scan page 8
PROPER TEACHING AND COOPERATION
Once again it's time to thank Cliff Jacobson for stirring the
waters and raising the issue of MCA cruise procedures’ and
responsibilities. Who else can put down a little ink and make
everybody in the organization excited about an issue? And I don't
mean that casually--as usual, the “little ink” has lots of thought
behind it, and the discussion will benefit each and every one of us.
I am not at all sure the board "disagrees with" Cliff's
recommendations, this is certainly not a "foregone fact." I think
the board is serious about improving all aspects of MCA offerings,
including cruises. I think we recognize there are inconsistencies
among cruisers, some of which reflect disoganization and may even
compromise safety. (The same could be said of every canoeing program
in this state; if you have a program you will have weaknesses, and
you must constantly monitor for safe practices.) It is a credit to
the MCA that these issues, considered dirty laundry in many
organizations, are hammered out in the glare of print. If some day a
court looks at these pages (which may be one of Cliff's
understandable fears), it will find what God probably finds in a
private conscience: three parts per million good intentions, two
parts per million legitimate pride in having done things right, and
the remainder an ocean of guilt for our collective failings.
Cliff's criticisms notwithstanding, let me express a little
optimism about the MCA cruise program.
First, if we had a paid cruise director, if we had leisure to
search the ranks of canoeists nationally and internationally, if we
had an infinite budget and could offer any wage, we would never find
a better cruise director than we have right now in Bill Simpson. I
would gladly stack Bill's canoeing experience, his knowledge of
camping and trip organization, his standards for safety, against
anyone else's. ‘Nuff said.
I want to also mention that our Education and Safety Director,
George Skinner, works very, very hard to emphasize education and
safety on the river for the MCA and other outdoor organizations.
Second, while the board admittedly moves painfully slowly, we are
working on improving the standards for cruises. The new first aid
kits are proof. There is talk of subsidizing first-aid training for
people who plan to lead MCA cruises; I hope we can provide this kind
of help. There is strong interest in leadership training.
Finally, I think it is to the board's credit that we do not jump
at doctrine (like Cliff's or, in fairness, any number of other
published methodologies) with our legislative stamp of approval.
Outdoor leadership is much too complex for dogma--from any source, no
matter how respected. In the final analysis, a leader can follow
aa last rule of the river and, with one slip in judgment (which
can hardly be taught, much less legislated) come up fatally short.
I have paddled in groups where the “lead" and “sweep" canoes were
unquestionably necessary, where the on-river organization had to be
obvious and rigorous. I have been with other groups where the idea
of "lead" and "sweep" would have been instantly interpreted (perhaps
rightly) as the leader's attempt to be mother ducky--to have all the
children neatly in _ Tine. Adults don't react well to this
heavy-handed authority, however beneficient its motivation.
Everything seems to depend on the circumstances--which leads us right
back to the issue of judgment.
I am all for looking at ways to tighten up the safety on MCA
cruises; I believe everyone on the board is in agreement on this.
But let's get beyond the confinements of arbitrary rules and
regulations. Let's get to the issue of instilling judgment based on
canoeing facts, and on the breadth of canoeing experience that our
organization brings to the sport.
--Don Mitchell, Vice-President
8 HUT!-October 1987
Article contents & approved summaries (0)
No article summaries are available for this view.