← Back to The HUT

September 1987 · Vol. 23 No. 9

September 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 9)

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 36 pages

September 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 9)

Captured text — scan page 16

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

A GESTURE

The stage is set: on the left we have a 17-foot aluminum canoe,
heavily laden with two adults and plenty of camping gear; on the
right a 20-foot runabout with five people and about 50 horsepower
for each of them. Both boat and canoe are under full power, but the
gap is closing, as you might expect, from right to left. No
collision course here; the two will clear by twenty yards or more.
The people of each craft, while aware of the other, are not much
concerned. Now, the gesture.

The boat pilot, a man of gentle breeding and good manners, pulls
back on the throttle sharply, interrupting the conversation and
causing the occupants of the boat to lean forward sharply. They
shade their eyes to look at the canoe more closely. It is, to them,
a gesture of good will. In the spirit of helpfulness, it has just a
touch of compassion for fellow creatures navigating the river in a
craft of considerably lesser means.

Instead of the return smile the boaters are anticipating,
however, the canoeists are scrambling into action, orienting their
craft as quickly as possible to align across a swell much greater
than they had expected. The bow of the canoe plunges heavily into
the wake, and the canoe rocks uncertainly for just a moment. Stable
again, the canoeists lean back and turn to look at the boat. Their
gesture is far from the anticipated smile.

Why does this scene recur, everyday, on every lake and river
where power boats and canoes coexist? Not because boaters are "bad
guys" and canoeists are “good guys." Because the two groups don't
communicate.

It is, of course, especially aggravating to be the recipient of
the boater's "slow-down" gesture when you are paddling the middle
reaches of the St. Croix, a well-marked "“no-wake" zone. Here the
boater is being nice by making the situation (already undesirable due
to his illegal speed) doubly hazardous due to half-speed. You are
not likely to catch up to the boat in this situation and explain your
tactful resentment! .

But even on other waterways, where the boat has at least an
arguable right to go any speed, (setting aside the marine axiom that
the craft of lesser power has the right of way), why are boat
opeators so unaware of the fact that their wake may be hazardous,
particularly when the boat is not planing? Whose job is it to inform
them?

The problem may be the residue of the amazingly fast evolution of
pleasure power boats. The ancient plodding cruisers which never
reached a "planing" speed may well have been able to help less stable
craft (canoes, sailboats, etc.) by simply slowing down. (Even
today's boats would help, if they slowed down enough.) But the habit
of slowing down a little is certainly no longer practical.

I'd like to have the MCA make a gesture of its own on this
subject. I'm sure within our membership we have many people
well-versed in both canoeing and power-boating (I am not, as may be
evident). I'd like to see an MCA policy statement on this situation,
that we could send to boat manufacturers, to boaters' associations,
to the DNR and the Coast Guard, as well as county-level waterway
enforcement personnel.

Who will help me put it together? Write or call:

Don Mitchell

Box 7

Marine on St. Croix, MN 55047
(612) 433-5367

16 HUT!-September 1987

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.