← Back to The HUT

September 1987 · Vol. 23 No. 9

September 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 9)

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 36 pages

September 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 9)

Captured text — scan page 28

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

CLIFF*S CORNER--MAGAZINE FIELD TESTS--BAH HUMBUG!

It's a familiar scene: The nattily clad
yuppie couple strolls into the equipment shop
in search of a specific new camping toy.
Clutched tightly in the man's right hand is
} the lastest issue of CANOEPACKERSKISPORT

Magazine, which this month features a
"thorough" evaluation of the product(s) in
question.

The article is a work of art, carefully
researched and designed to tell you everything
you could want to know about the product line.
"We pull no punches when it comes to the
truth," advises the publisher, "Whatcha see
is whatca get. We stand behind our ratings!"

So when the well-trained staff of the camp
shop shows Yvonne Yuppie and her boy friend
Lurch, the best of the product breed, the two
wince heartily and walk off in a_ huff,
unimpressed. Why? ""cause it says right here
in ‘CANOEPACKERSKISPORT that the Tri-lobed
Alpha-4 is the best tent. And if you ain't got one, we're goin'
elsewhere. Lookie here: It says this tent's sewn with 12 stitches
to the inch, not 6. Why, It's got to be better. Six threads will
rip for sure. C'mon, Yvonne, these folks are nerds. And they ain't
well read neither."

Okay, gang, let's cut through the fog. Here are the facts about
those "exclusive and complete" equipment tests you read--and take so
literally--in magazines.

First, some background: I've personally done quite a lot of
product testing, both for my own use and formally for magazines. In
every case, I've tried to be as fair as possible; I've enlisted the
help of others who were more familiar with the product, and I
experimented myself. But, there's only one of me, and like all
"field testers," I have only so much available time. On average, we
evaluators keep a product about four months before we return it to
the manufacturer. In evaluative format, we'll test ten or twenty
products, most of which we've never seen before the unopened box
arrives, No way can any single person, or even a team of people
provide foolproof results in this time frame.

Four months, you say? Long time, isn't it? Not really. The
actual using time per product jis ordinarily a matter of hours,
occasionally days. The rest of the time is spent researching,
writing manufacturers, and simply preparing the manuscript to
editorial specs. For those who aren't aware, magazines pay only for
the completed manuscript--often on a column-inch basis. Little
consideration is usually given to the time spent working with the
gear. Time is money, as they say. Most magazine evaluators have a
limited supply of both.

Then there's the matter of variables which don't fit the mold.
What looks good in the short run, often fails in time. For example:
Compare the Coleman Peak I stove with the venerable Svea 123. In
"evaluative terms" the Coleman starts easier, runs hotter, and is
more windproof. Weight the variables equally, and the Coleman is a
better buy, right? Maybe. The SVEA. on the other hand, features all
brass (rustproof) construction, and it has no plastic knobs or wires
to break. Its roarer burner is noisy but failproof--the geared
cleaning needle clears the jet of foreign matter with a single
counter-clockwise turn. But, you're on your own when the Peak I
clogs--or when it flares due to overfill. In time, you'll burn or
break the plastic knobs and wires. Eventually, the metal tank will
rust.

28 HUT!

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.