September 1987 · Vol. 23 No. 9
September 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 9)
Magazine · 36 pages
Search this issue
September 1987 Magazine (Vol. 23 No. 9)
Captured text — scan page 29
Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.
But, over the short haul, the Coleman is definitely the better
buy. In the long run, you may prefer the SVEA. Field-testers deal
with the "now" of things, and to some extent the forseeable future.
Only backwoods crazies can usually relate to the "far-seeable"
future.
There's also the matter of ad sales, which, as everyone knows,
are the life-blood of a magazine. Some years ago, an air-mattress
manufacturer threatened me with a multi-thousand dollar law suit
because I proclaimed that the air valve on their mattress (a wimpy
plastic affair) would eventually fail. The magazine quickly changed
the word "would" to "may," and I've been gleefully substituting it in
my writing ever since. After the article appeared, the mattress
company withdrew their advertising from the magazine, and that cost
my publisher a bundle. Moral: Panning brands--even if it's true--is
always a very very bad idea. Invariably, the truth hurts!
Consider now the Coleman canoe. Yes, I know Coleman laughed all
the way to the bank with this one. We're talking big buck
advertising here. The boys in Wichita pull no punches: Those full
page ads cost several grand. In HUT!, I'11 tell you honestly that
the Coleman performs somewhat better than a Tupperware bathtub--and
is, in fact, the only canoe I've seen that paddles worse than it
looks! But, I'll never write that in a magazine which depends on ad
copy for survival. What you read in HUT! are aboveboard impressions.
There's no pressure to "stretch" the truth.
Gore-tex is another product writers don't want to mess with. My
experience suggests it works great over the short haul--and it's
wonderful in winter--but it frequently fails in the long run. Take
Gore-tex on the typical 1-4 week canoe expedition and you may be
pleasantly surprised. Do it year after year, and you might be
dolefully enlightened.
There's also the matter of "weather." Suppose I had a new tent
to test on an arctic expedition and the weather shone peaches and
cream for a full month (it happens!). I'd say the tent was
comfortable, well-ventilated and it performed to full expectations.
That would be the truth, given the biased circumstances. Yet, the
manufacturer might claim his product was a well-tested expedition
tent that had seen the whites of the enemy's eyes.
These, then are the pitfalls of magazine product evaluations. To
suggest a "scientific" comparison, editors and evaluators resort to
all sorts of unrelated statistics. Variables such as weight, tear
strength, number of stitches per inch, etc. are all tabulated and
statistically weighted to produce a “one, two, or three star"
evaluation. In the end, the results often find opposite of intent.
Case in point, the Eureka Timberline tent. It has shlocky poles
and is sewn with only six stitches per inch. Construction features
are a step above dreadful. It's fairly heavy and time-consuming to
erect--all of which tend to down-grade its performance. Yet, the
design is quite marvelous: Rig it right, guy it out, and it'll take
quite a blow. Yet, compared to more lavish tents in the survey, it
falls short. The numbers tell the story: Other tents are superior
to the Timberline, even though they leak in the rain, and the
Timberline does not. That the Timberline does its intended job
without a whimper, is overshadowed by its poor quality construction
and limited comfort features.
So be it. Consider all the facts before you go gear shopping.
And leave your magazines at home. Try the product yourself, or take
along a friend who's "been there." And do talk heartily to those who
seek truth through experience. Believe some of what you read, more
of what you hear, and draw your own conclusions, and you'll receive
good value from each and every camp dollar.--Cliff Jacobson
September 1987-HUT! 29
Article contents & approved summaries (0)
No article summaries are available for this view.