January 1988 · Vol. 24 No. 1
January 1988 Magazine (Vol. 24 No. 1)
Magazine · 36 pages
Search this issue
January 1988 Magazine (Vol. 24 No. 1)
Captured text — scan page 14
Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.
CLIFF°S CORNER--MINNESOTA BRAINS
Some time ago, friends Bob Brown and Bruce
Kunz put on a solo canoe workshop for the
ladies of "Woodswomen." They fully expected
the women to prefer, by a wide margin, the
teeny twitchy canoes over the steady Eddy's.
To everyone's chagrin, the big boats--Pirate,
Mad River Ladyslipper II (the plug), Old Town
“CJ" and the like won out. Most of the ladies
. thought the "reasonably sized" canoes were
simply too small for backcountry tripping.
That's understandable. Most newcomers to
solo canoesport usually do prefer big boats to
small ones. Initially, they feel more
comfortable, more confident in a canoe of
‘larger size. And there's no denying that big
boats carry heavier loads and are _ more
seaworthy (usually) than smaller ones.
However, as you gain skill, you come to realize that you can get
along quite wel] in a boat which is considerably smaller than you
once had _ surmised. Suddenly you discover that a canoe of
"reasonable" size will perform to your expectations once you've
developed the “appropriate skills."
What is a "reasonable" size depends of course on your weight and
your perspective. people over 180 pounds should naturally choose
high volume craft in the 15-16 foot lenghth. But lighter folk can
get by fine in a narrow 14-15 footer.
In the 1890's when soloing was in its heyday, Henry Rushton
dogmatically recommended the 14 foot length. He believed that a
Tonger canoe (and by this he meant a "14-1/2 footer") was only
advantageous if the route included much open water. My sentiments
exactly!
It must be remembered, however, that nearly all of Rushton's
touring boats were fully decked, which explains their exemplary
performance in rough water. It's no secret that short canoes (about
13 feet) are best in whitewater while long ones (around 16 feet) are
ideal for making time on the flats. So it seems that Henry's
recommendation of 14 - 14-1/2 feet was “not far off" from what
honestly works best under a variety of conditions most of the time.
Every canoeist knows that you can't improve on one design
variable without detracting from another. Increase hul} speed and
you decrease maneuverablility. Increase maneuverability or capacity
and you decrease paddling ease, speed or portability--depending on
which variable you choose to accentuate. Thus, a solo canoe that
excels in one category will do only passing well in another.
If you're into magazine hype, you're apt to believe that you need
at least three solo canoes--one for mill pond play with a _ long
straight paddle, one for fast cruising ala sit ‘n switch, and one for
rough water, Fact is, you could easily rationalize owning four or
five specialized designs--that is, if you have lots of dollars and
want to churn them all into canoes.
A more “respectable” solution is to build or buy a single canoe
which is fun to paddle, yet versatile enough to perform acceptably
well in all categories--a possibility only if you're a skilled
paddler and equip the craft with a fabric splash cover. Covers cut
wind resistance by half or more, improve seaworthiness (rather, they
keep out water which is a function of seaworthiness) and keep you
warm, dry and in command regardless of the weather or the water
conditions.
14 HUT!-January 1988
Article contents & approved summaries (0)
No article summaries are available for this view.