March 1988 · Vol. 24 No. 3
March 1988 Magazine (Vol. 24 No. 3)
Magazine · 40 pages
Search this issue
March 1988 Magazine (Vol. 24 No. 3)
Captured text — scan page 16
Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.
REMEMBER~-CONTINUED FROM PAGE 15
The attitude that "only the best will do" is disturbing to me. I
want the very best that I can afford. That doesn't mean that I own
the best POSSIBLE in all my equipment. I have the best that MY money
can buy. Most of the canoeists and campers I know do the same.
Justifying the cost of expedition-quality gear would be very
difficult. I would rather go with a Eureka Timberline tent and spend
the difference on a good paddle. I don't need the bomb-proof gear
that is required on an expedition to the high arctic (or should I say
"real" canoe trip?).
This brings me to the main "axe" of this verbage. There is a
trend among a very few to promote the idea that only trips above the
50th or 60th parallel are "real" canoe trips. Unfortunately, my
friend Cliff is one of those who is a leader in this elitist cult.
Pick up a copy of CANOE magazine and: chances are you will find an
arcticle about one of his far-north jaunts. A lot of the magazine is
devoted to this type of "real" canoe trip. (Probably a good reason
why the magazine appeals only to a very small percentage of
canoeists and its circulation isn't what it could be.)
I would like to address my remarks directly to Cliff. What is a
"real" canoe trip? Do you believe that "real" trips can happen only
above the Canadian border or’ even the arctic circle? Does the trip
have to cost $1000 apiece and use a Twin Otter as part of the
transport? How about when you plan a trip for kids into the boundary
waters--do you announce it as not being a "real" trip? Next time you
see my daughter, Alexandra, will you tell her that the five days that
she and I spent on the Crow Wing River was not a "real" canoe trip?
Will you tell Verna that canoeing 135 miles on the Big Fork does not
constitute a "real" trip? When you talk to Bob Brown, will you tell
him that the trip he took years ago down the Vermillion with his kids
in his Herter's canoe was not a "real" trip?
The MCA has a mailing list of about 1300. This means that there
are probably four to five thousand people who are represented by our
organization. How many of them take "real" canoe trips?
You talk about forgetting our beginnings. How about you? Were
those trips you took in your scouting days not "real" trips? When
you went with what you had down a nearby river, it wasn't "real?"
Com'on Cliff. You talk about perspective. To use a cliche,
"Beauty is in the eye of the beholder." Ninety-five percent of the
MCA will never paddle more than 200 miles from home, let alone an
arctic river, You don't have to fly in to have a "real" trip. I
have watched people paddling the Namekagon and St. Croix for five
days and having an experience that meant as much to them as the Gull
or the Hood meant to you. Their experience was as "real" to them as
any of your deep wilderness trips. .
A couple of parting shots. Cliff, if you don't have the strength
to pull a Peak 1 out of a dented tin can, don't worry about bending
or breaking the "delicate" throttle lever--it's a whole lot stronger
than a tin can. I also suggest that you take a "real" close look at
the much-maligned Peak 1. Are those wires and knobs really that
"silly?" Are they really that "delicate?" How come all the Peak 1
owners I've talked to (and that's quite a few) never have had a
broken lever?
Regarding "obtuse." To that I say just because you are better at
grinding an axe doesn't make you the ONLY "sharp" one in the world.
I have learned many things from persons with only a little knowledge
of a given subject. Being an "expert" does not guarantee
infallibility.--James Robinson
16 HUT!-March 1988
Article contents & approved summaries (0)
No article summaries are available for this view.