← Back to The HUT

September 1988 · Vol. 24 No. 9

September 1988 Magazine (Vol. 24 No. 9)

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 40 pages

September 1988 Magazine (Vol. 24 No. 9)

Captured text — scan page 36

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

THE PERFECT SOLO CANOE

This summer I had the pleasure of spending a week in the Boundary
Waters in a group of four solo canoes. Out of these four canoes, we
had three different models, giving us the opportunity to test drive
and compare in different types of water, wind conditions, and loads.
The three designs were the CJ by Bell Canoe Works, Bob Brown's Strip
Traveler III and Bruce Kunz's Merlin, which I have faithfully and
lovingly paddled since its birth. Of these three models, which one
was the perfect canoe?

The CJ was paddled mainly by my father. He has trouble kneeling,
is a Jittle unbalanced in his coordination, and spends 85% of his
time fishing, or I should say, playing with his tackle. For him the
CJ was perfect. It was extremely stable, easy to maneuver, yet
tracked well across a few big lakes, one with a nasty quartering
headwind. There was plenty of room for all his gear including what I
thought was an enormous amount of fishing takcle and a thing I swear
looked like it could have been used as a down rigger. He's the type
that brings absolutely everything on a trip and can be particularly
smug when asked for things that we previously made fun of. He owned
a Merlin on last year's trip, but traded it in for a CJ this year.
He just felt more comfortable in a CJ.

My mother, on the other side of the spectrum, is slight of build,
extremely well balanced and carries a moderate amount of gear. She
also Jikes to fish, but probably spends most of that time making
additional tackle, playing chores for my father, like untangling her
line from rocks, herself, him (anything that gets in the way). She
spends a lot of time maneuvering around. For her, the Traveler III
was perfect. It was a sleek, and smaller canoe that performed. It's
like comparing a smal] sports car to a Cadillac. The Traveler III
responded like the sports car and fit like a well-worn comfortable
giove. If you like Bob Brown's Lady Slipper, you'll probably "die
and go to heaven" in the Traveler III.

My husband was probably the most experienced paddler in the group
and had the heaviest load at all times. He always gets the honor of
carrying the food and utensils, a fair amount of tackle, and our 90
Ib. golden retriever that tends to suddenly sit up or Jean over the
side at in-opportune times. The Merlin has always been and stil]
continues to be his canoe of choice. It tracked like an arrow and
didn't Jet the wind even think about pushing it around. The Merlin
was racy and had more horsepower than the CJ or the Traveler III
despite load conditions. And with a 350 1b. load, the Merlin, as
well as the CJ, had plenty of freeboard.

As for myself, I paddled the Traveler III most of the time and
thoroughly enjoyed it. The Traveler III was an easy canoe to feel at
one with and paddling seemed effortless. I should probably choose
this canoe for myself, but alas my background is in marathon canoes
and I'm a hit-and-switch paddler that craves going straight and fast
any time I see a body of water. The Merlin is still the canoe for
me. Although I have to tell you, when we put in on the Snake River
and I was in the Traveler III, it was a slice of heaven. It out
manuevered the Merlin and the CJ on this twisty little stream.

Now back to the perfect canoe. It's in the mind of the paddler,
taking into some consideration experience, physical build and
condition, type of paddler and intended use. Above all, it's just
plain how you feel about a canoe. And some of these criteria will
change with time spent on the water. As Minnesotan's, we have water
everywhere and that wonderful natural playground, the BWCA, is right
in our backyard: Our MCA members that design canoes are basically
designing them with Minnesota water in mind. So which one of these
member-designed canoes was the perfect or best canoe? It all
depends.....I'd say all three of them!--Elaine Bell

28 HUT!-September 1988

Articles (14) · Summaries (14)

Generated issue overview: September 1988 issue of HUT!, the monthly publication of the Minnesota Canoe Association. The issue includes canoe-trip reports, paddling and equipment articles, association news, event information, chapter material, advertisements, and membership and sales forms.

Generated summaries are descriptions, not original captured text. Page-range text shows complete scan pages and may include neighboring material.

From the Bow

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: The MCA president discusses upcoming board elections, work on revising the association bylaws, a kayaker's appearance in a Minnesota tourism commercial, and a meeting with a company interested in lightweight backcountry foods and sponsoring expeditions.

Open scan page 4

Read captured page 4 →

Book Review: Great Heart—The History of a Labrador Adventure

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: A review of Davidson and Rugge's account of the 1903 Hubbard expedition and the later expeditions by Mina Hubbard and Dillon Wallace. The reviewer praises the research and the book's treatment of the expedition's tragedy and controversy.

Open scan page 4

Read captured pages 4–5 →

BWCA, Quetico and Voyageurs: Eagles and Waterfalls Trip

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: A first-person account of a canoe trip from the Moose River through Lac La Croix and the Namakan River to Namakan Lake and the Ash River. The writer describes waterfalls, pictographs, campsites, wildlife encounters, route-finding, Bear Portage, and Kettle Falls.

Open scan page 8

Read captured pages 8–10 →

Around the Town with Mississippi Bob

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: Bob Brown reflects on the Hoigaard's racing series and a canoeing qualifier, promotes an October Mississippi River cleanup, and encourages readers to paddle in urban waters and improve their canoeing skills.

Open scan page 11

Read captured page 11 →

Another Look at Voyageurs National Park

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: The writer offers a positive account of a four-day canoe trip through Voyageurs National Park, describing its mix of wilderness, motorized recreation, historic sites, campsites, and the Kettle Falls Hotel. The article contrasts the park experience with a Boundary Waters trip.

Open scan page 12

Read captured pages 12–13 →

Trip Report on Canoe-a-Brunch, or the Only Place to Paddle Without Hitting Bottom

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: A report on a group canoe outing on the Mississippi River that used the St. Anthony locks, stopped for brunch, and returned to paddle near the falls in low water.

Open scan page 13

Read captured page 13 →

A Thank You to the MCA Board

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: Kate Kovar thanks the MCA for supporting her dragon boat experience and credits HUT! with introducing her to dragon boat racing, the Urban Canoe Series, and area races.

Open scan page 14

Read captured page 14 →

Area Women Stroke Out for Taiwan

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: A newspaper article about Kate Kovar and Rosanne Schoemehl joining the first U.S. Women's Dragon Boat Team for competitions in Taiwan and Hong Kong. It explains the sport and describes the team's international competition.

Open scan page 14

Read captured page 14 →

Clean Rivers for Canoeing

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: An overview of riverbank dumping in Minnesota and efforts to address it through state agencies and volunteer cleanups. The article describes cleanup initiatives, including an upcoming MCA cleanup on the Mississippi, and directs readers to a river-cleanup organizing kit.

Open scan page 19

Read captured pages 19–22 →

A Borrowed Sundowner

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: Bob Brown recounts returning to racing in a borrowed We-no-nah Sundowner, comparing its handling and speed with other canoes and discussing its performance in races and waves. He concludes that it is a strong choice for carrying gear on a trip.

Open scan page 30

Read captured page 30 →

More Sundowner

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: James Robinson responds to Bob Brown's Sundowner assessment, clarifying its behavior under load and discussing stability, hull dimensions, seat adjustment, and comparisons with the Jensen and Sawyer Cruiser.

Open scan page 31

Read captured page 31 →

Fall Color Cruise

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: Information for the MCA's annual fall outing on the St. Croix, including camping, Saturday route options, a shared chili meal, Sunday's color cruise, and the builders contest. The writer also reminds Minnesota residents about canoe registration.

Open scan page 32

Read captured page 32 →

Education and Safety: Canoeing the Far North Symposium

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: An update on the MCA's Arctic symposium, describing its planned slide presentations, venue, schedule, lodging choices, meal arrangements, and preregistration. It also mentions plans for wilderness first-aid courses.

Open scan page 32

Read captured pages 32–33 →

The Perfect Solo Canoe

Title transcribed from original publication

Generated summary: Elaine Bell compares three solo canoes—the Bell Canoe Works CJ, Strip Traveler III, and Merlin—based on how different paddlers and loads performed during a Boundary Waters trip. She concludes that the best canoe depends on the paddler, intended use, and personal preference.

Open scan page 36

Read captured page 36 →