← Back to The HUT

January 1973 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

January 1973 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 20 pages

January 1973 Magazine

Captured text — scan page 18

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

Vi Use of clearcutting be allowed only where: should be prohibited.
M CA States iews i. It is determined to be essential to ac- Superior National Forest. Motorboats and other
complish relevant forest management motorized craft should be allowed in the Su-

on BWC A objectives. perior, following the guidelnes of President
ii. The size of clearcut areas are keptat Nixon’s Executive Order of February 8, 1972.
: . a minimum and not over fifty acres. We feel that a reasonable number of trails of
Harold E. Anderson, Supervisor of Su- iii. These areas be shaped and blended as__ reasonable length should be established or main-
perior National Forest, has requested the much as possible with the natural prea in i sige for ee ie type
izations inter- terrain. a termined by the Supervisor to be compatible
ne in re oh OTC. fan resent iv. A multidisciplinary review has been_ with the area involved. The use of all types of
este us cOe ase OF MGC Paodlck made of the environmental, engin- motorized vehicles should be continually
our views on the Boundary Waters. The eering, economic, aesthetic, and bio- evaluated regarding their use, abuse, and impact.
following is our response. lopeal impacts of this proposed - PEOPLE AND L AND USE -
eats spe . We feel that dispersal of parties is essentia
Clearcutting should be prohibited where: : 7

We welcome this opportunity to comment i. Fragile soil, ee or slope con- in both the BWCA and Superior and should be
on the issues to be covered in the proposed Land ditions exist that would be subject to strongly recommended. This might be accom-
Use Plan being developed by the Forest Service major damage. plished by an improved educational system
for the Superior National Forest and the Bound- ii. There is no assurance that the area Which would present information on some, but
ary Waters Canoe Area. Because of the extreme can be adequately reforested within not all, areas and access points with lesser use.
importance of the latter, we prefer to treat it five years of harvest. We feel that this information should not be
separately from the Superior National Forest. ii. Outstanding or unusual aesthetic or SV" OP all areas but rather it be learned by
ci the Canoe Association’s ideas for man- natural conditions exist which would a. repeated visits to the BWCA and

aging the two areas are: be compromised by clearcutting. t ; : :
1. The BWCA should be managed in the In all cases a hate Goxite was eed by Another need is for an information center

in the metropolitan Twin City area. This center
would be capably staffed and would have the
function of accurately describing the experience
obtained in the various parts of the BWCA and

true spirit of the Wilderness Act, whatever techniques, the logger should post a
namely as a primitive area with as little performance bond before starting cutting. This
interference by man as possible. Itshould bond would be refunded when logging roads
be managed as a total ecological unit,not —_ were satisfactorily eliminated, the area refor-

as a series of smaller ones with different : Superior so that people not interested in the
Ge contlicaiae, purSGes, nt, ested and other terms of the contract completed. wilderness areas would be discouraged from

2. The Superior National Forest outside of - MINERALS - using them. They would be given suggestions
the BWCA should be managed not neces- We feel that there should be no mineralex- 0n other areas in the Superior and Chippewa
sarily as a completely primitive area, but _ploitation in either the BWCA or the Superior National Forests which would be more compat-
as a renewable forest resource under the unless a national emergency is declared by the ible to the type of experience they seek. We
multiple use concept. This would include _President of the United States and he deems the lo suggest that camping in the areas at the
economically feasible timber harvest and mineral resources to be necessary for the de- @dges of the BWCA be discouraged as these
timber management, wildlife habitat, fense of this country. We feel there should beno funnel many people into the area who are not

recreation, and other considerations. on-land exploration done other than by visual prepared to respect the wilderness area. _
- VEGETATION - or hand-tool techniques but that other non- We also recommend denial of permission to
destructive techniques, as developed, could be _local authorities for the upgrading of the Echo

Boundary Waters Canoe Area. The BWCA should i
: CAsI used. For example, a fly-over approved and su- Trail and other roads where they cross Federal

pe Tuainees gee Yael cooley HOE WHE persed by tie Forest Service could utilize mag- lands. A road only needs to be traversable, not

Ww: ICOM pa: “J unan ae as possible. netic or electronic instrumentation. The even- 2 first class highway. Wide, paved roads have an

y management necessary should be close to: tual goal should be for the U.S. government to _ adverse effect on the adjacent primitive areas.

ae oe es presently value and purchase all private mineral rights.
wheal tres tin Hae ead f £ gtk result of — Such valuation should be done in the least de-
: ques of prescribed burn- structive method available at the time
ing should be studied and adapted to conditions ~“SUCHve Method avat ee .
specific to the BWCA area so that they can be
used as management tools. The fire may be - WATER SUPPLY -
started by man or, if naturally started, should Boundary Waters Canoe Area. The dams present- KK*
be allowed to burn according to well thought- _ly in the BWCA should be allowed to continue .
out plans. If prescribed burning is not used, the _to disintegrate as they have been doing for the

buils-up of vegetation will continue unabated by _past several decades. Some friends of ours nave an interesting
natural means and an uncontrolled wild fire Superior National Forest. On areas outside of thing going for them, and for everyone
could result. the BWCA, some dams would have to be main- else too. They publish the Ecology Place-

We do not feel that logging in either the tained to protect certain areas where man has i 4
portal or interior zones is compatible with wil- intruded. However, the establishment of new — cape Ps Qs eat Liewesletie
derness but rather that it should be eliminated dams and level controls should be allowed only isting {O08 BO sue ed study ep? spa
from the list of available management options. to protect the area from hydrological disturp- ties dedicated to the preservation of our
Logging should be restricted to the Superior ances originating outside the area. Other dams Spaceship, and probably our souls as well.
3 onal Forest outside of the BWCA because in this area should be allowed to disintegrate if Write to Ecology Placement Service, 1711
of the shrinking amount of wilderness in the such action posed no threat or problem to the A ; z
United States. Present timber cutting contracts remaining area as determined by the Supervisor Lincoln Ave., St. Paul, Minnesota 55105

in the portal zone should not be completed if of the Superio i or call 690-3516.

the Forest Service and the holders of these con- one aa

tracts can agree on termination procedures and ‘- MOTORIZED VEHICLES -

compensation or substitution. For example, we 20undary Waters Canoe Area. We feel that mo- kk &
suggest that the contract holders be allowed to rized vehicles of any type are inconsistent with

cut an identical cordage of timber of the same 2 Primitive wilderness area. An ultimate goal of
or equally valuable species in the Superior out- _ the Forest Service, therefore, should be the pro-
side of the BWCA. hibition of any motors in the BWCA except for
Superior National Forest. Logging should be al- US€ by Forest Service personnel. Such a recom-
lowed in the Superior under the multiple use | ™endation should be strongly made by the For-
concept. The Superior could also be usedinex- St Service to the U. S. Congress repeatedly
perimentation to determine proper techniques Until such a law is passed.

for managing it as a timber resource as well as For the present, we suggest the concept of
for recreation and other uses. We suggest that | temporal zoning of motors. This would involve
logging in this area be conducted under guide- the prohibition of motors in most areas except
lines recommended by the Senate Subcommittee | for the early months of the fishing season wnen
on Forestry. These include periodic reviews of | Motor use is greatest. In some areas of continual
the allowable harvest to assure that the landsare Ptesent heavy use, they would not be restricted
available and suitable for timber production; immediately. We feel that all snowmobiles and
that increases in harvest allowances based on Off-road recreational vehicles should be banned
reforestation, thinning, etc. be made only if from the BWCA. The Wilderness Act specifical-
these techniques justify increased allowances ly mentions established uses of motorboats. A
and that proper funds are available and used for | snowmobile or other recreational vehicle is not
these purposes. Some clearcutting guidelines we a boat but rather has a different influence on :

believe practicable include: the land and its residents and other users. These American Canoe Asscciation

16 HUT! JANUARY 1973

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.