← Back to The HUT

March 1973 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

March 1973 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 20 pages

March 1973 Magazine

Captured text — scan page 16

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

The BWCA Mineral Rights Problem

By Al Buchholz

BACKGROUND

The recent decision by Judge Philip
Neville to grant a permanent injunction
against mineral exploration and extraction
in Minnesota’s Boundary Waters Canoe
Area is an extremely important one in the
fight to preserve wilderness. The mineral
rights problem which the Judge dealt with
has its roots in the practices and laws of
the turn of the century. In 1905 the
Minnesota legislature passed a bill to allow
separation of the rights to subsurface
minerals from surface rights in land trans-
actions. In 1914 the Minnesota Supreme
Court ruled that several subsurface hold- MINNESOTA
ings must be taxed separately from surface
real estate. The net effect was to exclude
unexplored mineral rights from taxation.

In Northern Minnesota, the landowners
at that time were the railroads and log-
ging companies. The area was rich in vir-
gin forests. After logging their land, the the Romibaiy Waters Cann nate
owners would often let the surface prop-
erty revert to the state for failure to pay
taxes but retain the subsurface rights.
Over the years these subsurface rights
were sold and divided so that today much
of the subsurface mineral rights of North-
ern Minnesota are scattered among many
owners, often not easily found. In an ef- Zi
fort to clear up the confusion, the 1969 4 '
Minnesota legislature passed a law requir- All-wsather'camp
ing subsurface rights to be registered by B og toward L.
1974. Failure to register would permit the & PeterL.
state to act as a leasing agent and collect a ok ee
royalties until the owner registers. The .

purpose was to obtain a listing of owners. Gabimichigami L. came LYS rscr0 te

CANADA

Pigeon R.

GRAND PORTAGE &

ELY @

'] GRAND MARAIS
@

Lake Superior

@ VIRGINIA
Shaded area indicates BWCA

Trails End

CANADA

Other Minnesota laws provide that min-
eral rights be subject to the same taxation
as real estate taxes. However, this requires
i a assessment before taxes can be St. Clair’s Proposed Test Drilling Sites
vied.
What are mineral rights? As the name

suggests, these are the rights to ownership because of compromises in the legislative treat the primitive wilderness qualities of
of any mineral deposits found in, on, or process throughout the history of the the BWCA as most important. Thus, a
under a specific parcel of land. These | BWCA. When national forests were setup, egal decision was necessary to clear the
rights are pre-eminent over all other types it was common to allow mineral explora- problem.

of real estate laws. They allow the holder __ tion and logging in these areas. These laws When the original Superior Roadless
to exploit the minerals even if it means were passed before most of the publichad Area was set up and land additions added
moving surface real estate or destroying am appreciation of wilderness areas and to it, not enough money was available to
whatever is on the surface covering the | While our country still was under the purchase all the mineral rights. Also some
minerals. Two famous examples of this frontier philosophy of easy exploitation. private land holdings were not obtained.
are the cities of Hibbing, Minnesota and ‘In addition the 1964 Wilderness Act al- In today’s one million acre BWCA (part
Butte, Montana where whole neighbor- lowed prospecting and other activities in of the 3 million acre Superior National
hoods have had to be moved because of public lands as long as “such activity is Forest) the land and mineral ownership is

Jerry L. @ Sample Drillings

valuable mineral deposits underneath. carried on in a manner compatible with broken down into the following pattern:
The BWCA Mineral Rights Suit is an the preservation of the wilderness

attempt to prevent a New York business- vironment”. Other important excep- Ownership of the BWCA

man, George St. Clair, from exercising tons allow entrance and exit regulations Land Mineral Rights

mineral rights to explore and later extract consistent with the use of the land for United States 71.3% 44.0%

any mineral: he foundin 150,000 acresof drilling and mining operations, especially Minnesota 2%6 3 ° 263 °

the BWCA vest of the Gunflint Trail. Mr. in private holdings within public wilder- — 14 14

St. Clair ‘ad leased or owned mineral ness areas. Opposed to these exceptions Privuist 10 283
rights in the area of Gabimichigami and _are the rules and regulations set forth by y : .

other lakes in the heart of one of the main _ the Department of Agriculture in manag- The 1% of private land ownership is grad-
BWCA watersheds. The problem arose ing the BWCA as a wilderness. These rules _ ually reverting to the Federal government

14 HUT! MARCH 1973

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.