← Back to The HUT

March 1973 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

March 1973 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 20 pages

March 1973 Magazine

Captured text — scan page 17

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

by condemnation and expiration of life- . drill, or remove minerals was sought. The agreed to rule on whether Congress had in
time leases. injunction would also prohibit the Feder- effect zoned out mineral exploration and

al and State officials from granting per- mining when it declared the BWCA a
Ss OF THE SUIT mission to St. Clair to enter their ads wilderness and, therefore, had invalidated

During the summer of 1969, George and waters or to bring inequipment. The _ mineral rights in that area.

St. Clair hired geologists to explore the actual claims of the League suit contend By June, 1971, the Judge had decided
surface of the land under which he held that St. Clair and his lessors have waited to add as defendants the companies who
or leased mineral rights. This land waslo- until the public appreciation of wilder- had leased their mineral rights to St. Clair.
cated near Gabimichigami, Gillis, Howard, ness was strong to enter their claimstothe And, in August, 1971, the State of Min-
Peter and French Lakes in the Northeast mineral rights ina wilderness area to which nesota added a claim that the mineral
part of the BWCA, just west of the Gun- they have never paid taxes and thus the sights were invalid because they had been
flint Trail. This area is part of a large mineral rights are forfeited. Other claims obtained fraudulently by others in the
arc-shaped rock formation known as the contend that the exploration for and the 1880’s and 1890’s. During that time,
Duluth Gabbro which extends from the removal of minerals will irreparably harm Northern Minnesota was opened up to
Duluth area to the Canadian Border near the public’s use and enjoyment of the homesteaders provided they lived on the
the end of the Gunflint Trail. The Duluth BWCA and that St. Clair’s actions are in- land. A Federal investigation in 1894
Gabbro is thought to have low-grade cop- compatible with the Wilderness Act of showed that very few homesteaders lived
per-nickel ores in it. Not only does the 1964, other laws as well, and the long- in that area and that the railroads and log-
area St. Clair is interested in contain standing policy of the United States and ging companies had paid people to claim
mineral potential, but it also is in the Minnesota to maintain the BWCA in its the land as homesteaders so that it could

heart of one of the few remaining virgin _ primitive state. be logged and the mineral rights separated.
(unlogged) forest areas in the BWCA’s Mr. St. Clair’s lawyers claimed that In October, 1971, the final briefs were
no-cut zone. Congress did not intend to ban mineral filed by both sides and on May 15, 1972,

St. Clair’s men set up a semi-perma- rights in wilderness areas and that evenif Judge Neville ruled that the Federal gov-
nent camp on the shore of Howard Lake, it had so intended, the attempt wouldvio- ernment, not the State, had the right to
in violation of the Forest Service’s two- late his property rights without due proc- challenge whether the mineral rights were
week camping allowance. When the Forest ess of law. The Federal government de- obtained fraudulently. He also ruled that
Service found out about the camp, it fendants claimed that the League suit was the Federal government had allowed the
ordered St. Clair to remove it from the premature and should be thrown out be- six-year statute of limitations to expire
BWCA. Instead he cacheditandinDecem- cause the Forest Service never had a and, therefore, could do nothing about
ber, 1969, he informed the Forest Service chance to pass on St. Clair’s application them. He did comment that “exhibits and
he intended to move drilling equipment for core drilling in the BWCA. These de- _ briefs presented would indicate some sub-
into the area to test drill holesup to 600 _fendants asked for the suit to be dismissed. stance to the claim had it been timely
ft. deep in search of minerals. According In February, 1970, the Federaldefend- presented years ago”. Final arguments
to news sources, he did not ask permission ants wanted to be removed from the suit were held in September, 1972, and on
to move mechanized equipment into the because they had impounded St. Clair’s January 4, 1973, Judge Neville issued a
BWCA as required by the 1965 BWCA equipment and claimed that no further ac- permanent injunction against prospecting
éSouladons, In This 1969 and cart 7 tivity was planned by St. Clair until the or mining for minerals in the Boundary
Sr conker d same he nie — Judge had ruled on the suit. They also Waters Canoe Area.

discovered and on Jan. 29, 1970, the For- ae Boner eerie etapa THE JUDGE’S DECISION
est Service removed andimpoundedthem. .. 4 : The League’s suit contended that the
About this time, the Izaak Walton League injunction and could not dictate how Fed- BWCA has been effectively zoned as a

: _ © eral property should be used. In June, . —_ : -
ee see pe ld eee - 1970, Judge Neville denied the Federal wilderness and against commercial activ

Federal government to prevent St. Clair case and said that the Federal government ie oe ta, itis pent td an
from stieaton To reach his proposed must stay in the suit and can be sued with- BWCA ‘a ciscianes and prohibitions are
drilling sites, he would have to cross Fed- Ut Hy GOREN. dat Cepecially Important :

: reasonable since zoning rarely takes place
eral and State lands as well as water ruling was also that the Izaak Walton without someone being deprived of the

ats - League can sue because of its long-stand- : :

Seats), The taaak Welton Usage bavlon ing interest in the Boundary Waters and by eovernmental bodies i well established
rig : A as “aesthetic, conservational, and recre- : F F

tons to the BWCA nd Superior National t0nal interest to protect.” Special note jv ces which upheld this decision
Forest since its foundin in| 922 was taken of the League’s purchase of A second site Judge ruled on was

The League filed its suit on Januar over 7,000 acres and later transfered to whether St Clait had forfeited his mineral
7, 1970, in the US. District Court. De- Sold them to the Federal government at Tic by not exercising them while the
fendants were George St. Clair, Thomas ° lessthen Ete ppimeainiser pn. Sipedor National Forest and the BWCA
Yawkey, the Secretary of Agriculture and In the meantime (early 1970), the were being promoted and developed. The
his employees, the Chief of the U.S. For- State of Minnesota had filed a cross claim fact that he had never paid any Minnesota
est Service and the Supervisor of the in support of the League with the added real estate taxes on them was also a part
Superior National Forest. State officials provision that the area be explored only of the point. The Judge ruled that “there
who were also defendants were the Com- _ in a national emergency. is no merit in the bare bones contention
missioner of Conservation (now Commis- By January, 1971, it was determined that failure to pay any real estate taxes on
sioner of Natural Resources) and the that Thomas Yawkey, owner of the Bos- mineral rights in some way or other for-
Commissioner of Taxation. The nature ton Red Sox, had no longer any title or feits them...”. Because the present law
of the claims were to seek a ruling to de- leases to mineral rights and he was dis- allows the separation of mineral rights and
termine St. Clair’s mineral ‘rights and missed as a defendant provided he agree no payment of taxes without any assess-
titles and to interpret the State and Fed- to abide by the Judge’s ultimate decision. ment, St. Clair and his lessors were ruled
eral land use zoning laws governing the At that time, Judge Neville agreed to rule _ not to have abandoned their mineral rights.
rights to remove minerals and regulating on the question whether St. Clair had However, the fact that they did not exer-
other activities. Pending the decision, an _ forfeited his mineral rights because he had cise them while the public areas were
injunction prohibiting St. Clair or his peo- not paid taxes on them and had failed to _ being set up and defended, the court de-
ple from entering the BWCA to explore, —_ exercise them before 1969. The Judgealso _ cided that there would be no injustice done

HUT! MARCH 1973 15

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.