← Back to The HUT

March 1973 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

March 1973 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 20 pages

March 1973 Magazine

Captured text — scan page 18

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

if the “defendants are held to be some
sort of constructive trustees for the public
on the basis of being speculators knowing
the trend of the BWCA development
history”’.

Judge Neville also ruled that St. Clair
and the mineral rights owners would have
to cross State controlled waters and both
State and Federal land to gain access to
their mineral rights. No easements have
been granted and any such access would
destroy the wilderness and should not be
allowed.

The Judge ruled against the Federal
government claims that they had not had
a chance to rule on St. Clair’s drilling ap-
plication and, therefore, the League suit
was premature. He felt that the Forest
Service did permit St. Clair’s people to
enter the BWCA and granted them an ex-
ception from the regulations for estab-
lishing a base camp and did not immedi-
ately reject St. Clair’s drilling application.
He ruled that this showed the Forest Serv-
ice intent and that the League’s suit to seek
a permanent injunction was valid.

Thus the Judge concluded that Con-
gress has the right to zone and that the
decision before him was primarily to ans-
wer the question whether Congress intend-
ed to zone mineral exploration and re-
moval out of the BWCA wilderness area.
In a long conclusion, he decided that Con-
gress did, in fact, intend that the BWCA
be managed as a wilderness and that min-
eral activity and wilderness are incom-
patible. Further he stated in his decision
that, “In this court’s opinion, the wilder-
ness objectives override the contrary min-
eral right of the statute [i.e. the Wilder-
ness Act] (and of necessity the regulations
promulgated pursuant thereto).” He also
stated that “to create wilderness and in
the same breath allow for its destruction
could not have been the real congressional
intent...” He also held that mere pros-
pecting and drilling is an encroachment
on the wilderness. The Judge’s final com-
ments dealt with the State of Minnesota’s
request that the injunction be granted “ex-
cept as related to a national emergency.”
Judge Neville commented that these terms
are so broad that a national emergency
could be a declaration of war, a civil war,
or a shortage of metals requiring imports.
He felt that this national emergency clause
should not be allowed until the Congress
has defined what it would mean.

THE INJUNCTION

What did the Judge grant? First of all,
he issued an order for a permanent injunc-
tion barring St. Clair, his lessors, and their
people “from attempting directly or in-
directly mineral exploration or in any
other way the exercise of mineral rights in
or under land situated within. . the BWCA
in Minnesota.” The permanent injunction
also prohibited the Secretary of Agricul-
ture, the Chief of the Forest Service, the
Supervisor of the Superior National For-
est, the Commissioner of Conservation or
the Commissioner of Taxation from per-

16 HUT! MARCH 1973

mitting any of the others from trying to What can we do? First of all, a de-
exercise mineral rights in the BWCA. This cision does not mean that the costs of
order also applies to any successors, egal action are over. In spite of the law-
agents, etc. of the defendants. yers and others who donated all or most

of their time for this case, the expenses

WHAT NEXT? still total thousands of dollars. If an ap- |

While a major battle appears to have peal is sought, the costs will continue to
been won, the total war is still not over. escalate. So your help is still needed. Even
At press time, word was that at leastsome one dollar helps! If you use the BWCA or
of the defendants had taken the initial want to ensure that it will still be there
steps to appeal Judge Neville’s decision.I for the future, how about sending a con-
think that this lawsuit is a good example tribution to the BWCA Defense Fund c/o
of how lengthy and complicated legal pro- The Minnesota Canoe Association, P.O.
ceedings appear to the layman but how Box 14177, University Station, Minneapo-
necessary they often are to ensure that lis, Minn. 55414. The old saw that the
laws and regulations be applied where price of eternal wilderness is eternal vig-
intended. ilance still applies.

kkk kkk &
Whitewater Cruising — 1973

A repertoire of fine rivers and able Paddlers are expected to call or write
cruise leaders for the Spring 1973 white- their respective cruise leader during the
water season has been established. The week prior to the cruise. Meet at the ren-
rivers have been carefully selected to take dezvous point at the scheduling time.
best advantage of the spring runoff. These Membership in the MCA is not required.

rivers are expected to be grade III at the Summer and Fall cruises will be planned
selected dates but, like long range weather as interest and water levels dictate. Some
forecasting, we can’t be sure. potential cruises are:

All participants must be good swim-
mers and wear life jackets and protective e North Shore (Brule, Temperance,
headgear. A wet suit is necessary until Pigeon, Baptism, Cloquet, St. Louis)
mid-May. Experienced paddlers in open e Land of the midnite sun and hockey
canoes are welcome, but additional floata- pucks (Vermillion, Sturgeon)
tion, such as a large inner tube stuffed e Midsummer nite’s werewolf special
under the thwarts, is required. Decked (midnite, full moon run of Hell’s
boats must have adequate floatation and Gate)
‘grab loops. e Fall color (Wolf & Pestigo)

April-May Whitewater Cruise Schedule

DATE RIVER RENDEZVOUS POINT TIME LEADER PHONE
April 8 Sand Picnic area in Jordan, Noon Andy Westerhaus 890-1161
Minn. (Highway 21
bridge)
April14 Bois Brule Campground in Brule, 11:00 AM John Krack 566-1984 (home)
15 Totogatic* Wis. 633-6170
x 5178 (work)
April 21 S.F.Flambeau Landing, Hwy. M 10:00 AM Tom Johns 560-1058
22 Jump* North of Hawkins :
April 28 Kettle River Race
29
May 5 Snake County Campground 11:00 AM Steve Parsons 521-4789 (work)
3 mi. north of
Woodland : .
May 12 Kettle Head of the rapidsin 10:00 AM Joerg Steinback 636-0114

Banning State Park
May 19 Apple River Race
20

May 26 E.B. Ontonagon* Highway 45 bridge 11:00 AM Andy Westerhaus 890-1161
near Mass, Mich.

27. ~Ford*
28 Menomonee*, Pine*, or Popple*

*Denotes Exploratory Cruise

4

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.