← Back to The HUT

September 1973 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

September 1973 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 16 pages

September 1973 Magazine

Captured text — scan page 11

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

available for study and comment, and we
Re ort — Izaak Walton can form our own opinions as to how
well this has been done.) The differences
5; a between the viewpoints of the members
Le a U e C n V t of the panel were not surprising, but, what
g O en ion was interesting was their areas of agree-
ment. Each one, in his own presentation,

by Paul Toren both as “The Morality of Management” made the point that we must accept a ~
and as “The Mortality of Management”. decreased freedom of access and use, if
It’s not hard to see why many canoe I don’t know which it was supposed to the BWCA is to be maintained as a rea-
enthusiasts are also actively concerned be, but both of them were really correct. sonable facsimile of a wilderness area.
about the preservation and proper man- Dr. Mech described the background and Sig Olson expressed the general feeling
agement of our natural environment, rationale of the management plan, and to during the discussion period when he
since much of the enjoyment of canoeing. my mind presented a conclusive case for commented he had never thought to see
depends on the quality of the lakes and its adoption. Mr. Regenstein’s presenta- the time when he couldn’t put in his
streams we use. With this in mind, I sup- tion was a disappointment to me, since it canoe and travel as he pleased in the
pose that an article in HUT about the consisted mostly of quotations, out of BWCA, but he could see that restrictions
Izaak Walton League is not inappropriate, context, from Mech’s book, and repeated would soon be needed to preserve the area.
especially in view of the long time in- assertions that the Forest Service, the While the educational and informa-
volvement of the Ikes in the establish- DNR, and anyone else in favor of the tional program of the convention was
ment and preservation of the Boundary management plan was deliberately at- going on, a number of delegates were
Waters Canoe Area. I was asked to write tempting to exterminate the timber wolf wrestling with the policy statements and
about the League’s recent national con- in Minnesota. As the result of the efforts resolutions to be presented to the full
vention in Duluth, which I will do. Iwill of groups such as the Fund for Animals, convention for action on the last day of
also try to include a more general idea of the wolf now has no protection whatso- the meeting. Any member, or chapter,
how this national conservation organiza- ever in Minnesota, which makes me won- _ of the League can submit such resolutions
tion sets its policies and carries on its der if these groups are really concerned for consideration before the convention

work. with the true situation, or only with some meets. They are studied, discussed, re-

First a little background. The IWLA abstract idea of “nature” untouched by written, modified and sometimes rejected
is a 50 year old, national organization the presence of man. by the resolutions committee and by
with about 50,000 members (3000 in No Izaak Walton meeting in Minnesota several special area task groups. For ex-

Minnesota). Although its areas of interest is complete without a session on the ample, I sat in with a group on energy
encompass the entire environment, natu- BWCA, and this one was no exception. policy, and worked on proposals including
ral and man-made, its forty-plus years Again we had the opportunity of hearing energy conservation, nuclear power plants,
of committment to the BWCA give it a several points of view. First was Sig and the Alaska pipeline. The resolutions
special place with those who know and Olson, speaking from over forty years of which we prepared then went to the full
use that particular area. working with the Ikes, first as a con- resolutions committee and then to the
An anthropologist has recently drawn cerned member and later as our National convention for discussion and voting.
a parallel between environmental con- Wilderness Consultant. He spoke of the These resolutions, as approved by the
frontations, Earth Day symposia and BWCA as a unique and irreplacable natu- convention, become our stated policy and
other “eco-oriented” activities, and reviv- ral area, which must be preserved just be- the basis for action by our legislative
al meetings of a religious sect. I suspect cause of what it is, and because of what committees and other working groups. I
that an IWLA convention also fits this de- it means to those who care about main- won't try to mention them all — there
scription, although most of those attend- ing at least a few areas where nature, and Were about 30 of them passed, covering
ing are already “converted”, and find in not man, has primacy. Next we heard the country from Big Cypress Swamp”
the personal contacts and the formal pro- from Ron Walls, an Ely attorney who to “Oregon Wilderness”, and including
gram of the convention a means of con- recently represented the timber com- Subjects all the way from “Urban Envi-
firming and strengthening their faith. It panies in litigation concerned with the ‘onment” to “Wingdams, Jetties, and
seemed to me, however, that this meeting BWCA. His main point was that a well Groins”. We passed a resolution reaffirm-
went beyond this in that most of the pre- managed program of lumbering, in the ing the League’s position on the BWCA
sentations included representatives of the Portal Zone for example, need not inter- (no commercial logging or mechanized
“enemy” as well as those we agreed with, fere with the recreational use of the area, transport) which we first adopted in 1964.
and we had the opportunity of weighing and would in fact be of benefit in improv- We approved a general policy with respect
more than one side of the questions. I ing wildlife habitat and variety of vegeta- to off-road vehicles, that their use be pro-
can’t pretend to give a full report or what tion. Third on the panel was John Waters, hibited on public lands, except where ex-
transpired at the convention. What fol- of Canadian Waters canoe outfitters. As pressly permitted as part of a rational and
lows are things that I remember and that he pointed out, conscientious outfitters well enforced management plan. There
I think might be of interest to MCA are caught in a dilemma -- realizing that were others which are of direct interest
members. their incomes depend on more people to Minnesotans and canoers, but this
using their services, but also that too should be enough to indicate the type of
The present and future status of the many people in the BWCA can destroy things the League is concerned with.
timber wolf was the subject of a discus- the area, and the outfitting business as The Izaak Walton League and the
sion, or confrontation, between Dr. David well. The fourth member of the panel Minnesota Canoe Association have many
Mech, well known wild-life biologist who was Harold Andersen, Supervisor of the interests in common, and I feel personal-
was one of the authors of the proposed Superior National Forest, the man who ly that belonging to both groups is a
timber wolf management plan for Minne- has to resolve these conflicts of interests natural expression of this. Speaking as an
sota, and Mr. Lewis Regenstein, National and viewpoints, and manage the BWCA officer of the Minnesota Izaak Walton
Director of the Fund for Animals and a_ for the best long range interest of the League, I would be pleased to see’more
major contributor to the defeat of this public. (By the time this article is printed, MCA members join us, and would be hap-
plan in the recent legislative session. The — the long awaited management plan forthe py to supply more information to anyone
convention program had this session titled Superior Forest and the BWCA should be interested.

HUT! SEPTEMBER 1973 9

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.