August 1977 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown
August 1977 Magazine
Magazine · 12 pages
Search this issue
For the full-resolution original, use Open PDF above. Your browser handles PDF zoom and navigation.
Searchable text for scan page 8
Royalex Review
BY CLIFF JACOBSON
—Two popular ABS/foam canoes: The Old Town 17’
2” Tripper, and the 16’3”’ Mad River Explorer—
Sometime ago, I reported my impression of the then WEIGHT
new kevlar built Sawyer “Charger”. After three years of
ownership and many paddle miles, the Charger still remains Old Town advertises its Tripper at 77 pounds, and that’s
my favorite boat. A canoe enthusiast, however, needs at about right. Bob Dannert’s Tripper weights 75 pounds;
least two canoes (I’d like three or four but neither my Bob Henry’s weighs 72 pounds.
garage, my budget, nor my wife will permit that). So I Catalog weight of the Mad River Explorer, according to
sold my old shoe-keeled, fabric-decked Grumman and went “Wilderness Camping” Magazine’s 1977 buyer’s guide, is
in search of a suitable replacement. 70 pounds. Mine weighs 80 pounds right on the nose.
I bought a 16 foot Mad River Explorer, in Royalex. Mad River earlier advertised this model at 65 pounds. I
I’ve lived with the boat for two seasons now and figure doubt that you'll find one that light—-anywhere. Identical
it’s time to share my impressions of it with fellow paddlers. Royalex hulls may vary greatly in weight. Take your
Mad River’s been selling a lot of Explorers, and EMS (The bathroom scale with you when shopping Royalex.
Lob Pine) in St. Paul, is a major distributor of the line. SPEED
[Ive also had the opportunity to paddle an Old Town
17’2” “Oltonar” (a fancy name for reinforced Royalex The Old Town Tripper is much faster than the Mad
built to Old Town’s specs) Tripper. The two boats are River Explorer. It paddles easily, even when heavily loaded,
both constructed of foam ABS, but they are VERY dis- and rides about one inch higher than the shorter Mad River
similar. Here are my findings: boat with an equal load. This tells you something about the
Mad River’s design. In marathon terminology, the Explorer
ADVERTISED SPECS is a “river pig”. Its stems are wider BELOW the water line
than above it. Result: the short boat pushes a sizeable bow
The Royalex Explorer IS NOT the same boat as the wave at any speed and its tail gurgles happily. The Old
Kevlar Explorer. The kevlar model is six inches longer; it Town slips quietly through the water with scarcely a
has finer ends, and it’s much lighter and faster than the whisper. (Don’t mis-judge the boat. It can’t compare to a
Royalex model. USCA cruiser or an 18% foot high-sided white water racer
for speed or silence). Bob Dannert and I took his Tripper
DEPTH down the Minnesota Snake last year and through Slough
Gundy on the Flambeau. The boat stayed dry as a bone
Old Town advertises a 15 inch depth. That’s correct; the throughout both runs and was perhaps five percent faster
mid-ship depth measures almost exactly 15 inches. Mad than his 18 foot Grumman.
River also specifies a 15 inch depth. That’s incorrect; mine
measures 14 inches-even less when the canoe is in the MANEUVERABILITY
water. This is because the keel-line hogs about one-half
inch when the boat is afloat. The usable depth of my The Old Town turns, but not fast. The shorter Mad
Explorer is thus about 13% inches. Not as bad as it sounds, River is more responsive and seems better for use in boulder
though; the bottom holds its shape reasonable well. The gardens where quick turns are essential. The front seat on
Old Town’s bottom is slightly rounded, so it holds it the Tripper is well back. This gives the boat good lift in
shape better than the Mad River. Honest depth of the Old heavy water but makes for a long paddle reach over the side
Town Tripper is very close to its advertised 15 inches. as well as reducing turning leverage at the ends. Two good
paddlers, though, can spin the Old Town quickly with a
STABILITY powerful “draw”. The Mad River, however, when layed
slightly on its side, turns almost as easily as a shoe-keeled
The Explorer has higher initial stability than the Tripper. 17 foot Grumman.
The shallow vee bottom of the Explorer permits it to track
reasonably well, though it requires more attention than the PROBLEMS
Old Town, with its shallow arch (slightly rounded) bottom.
The Old Town Tripper feels “wiggly” in comparison to All Royalex hulls are slippery as hell on the inside,
the Mad River Explorer. The Explorer is better for trips Rugge and Davidson, in their “Complete Wilderness Pad-
with kids and dogs who don’t stay put in crucial situations. dler”, suggest glueing pieces of inner tube to the inside of
the hull with contact cement. This works fine but messes
AESTHETICS up the boat if you want to sell it later. Bathtub skid tape
doesn’t work at all—at least not for long. I’ve had good luck
The Explorer is a pretty boat. It beats the Old Town by with closed cell foam and duct tape. Just tape the foam to
a mile. Tricked out with ash rails, caned seats, and black the bottom of the boat. Ensolite works fine but gets brittle
fiberglass decks, the Explorer makes the Old Town look and cracks because it is badly degraded by the sun. EVA
austere by comparison. Where the Old Town draws com- (ethyl-vinyl-acetate) foam is ideal, as is Volarafoam. Both
ments, the Mad River invites ‘“oohs, aah’s” and approving foams are light, naturally buoyant, resistant to sunlight,
stares. skid-proof, and soft enough to prevent sore knees.
Hut Page 7
Article contents & approved summaries (0)
No article summaries are available for this view.