← Back to The HUT

February 1979 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

February 1979 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 12 pages

For the full-resolution original, use Open PDF above. Your browser handles PDF zoom and navigation.

Scan page 5 of February 1979 Magazine
Searchable text for scan page 5

CLOQUET RIVER PLAN REASONABLE
By Thomas P. Keaveny

Recent actions regarding zoning and desig-
nation of Minnesota's Cloquet River have rekindled
the fiery debates which commonly surrounds
situations of this nature.

Several factions are opposing inclusion of
the Cloquet River in the State Wild and Scenic
Rivers System. The most notable example, the
People's Property Rights Association, alleges
membership of some 1,400 people involved with
property rights issues. However, critical data
have been overstated and represented inaccurately
while several key considerations have gone
unnoticed.

Thé designation proposal calls for a
description of present zoning and potential
impacts of mining, management recommendations
and proposed rules and regulations to preserve
and protect the river...Land use management or
zoning would be implemented by St. Louis and Lake
counties and townships along the river.

Th proposal recommends that only 80 acres,
or a half-mile of the river's 200 shoreline miles
be acquired for purposes of legitimate access.

Developed lakeshores on Island, Alden, Side
and Hunter lakes are not included in any of
the plans, and homes could still be built along
the river.

St. Louis County planning data indicate
63 shoreline miles are owned by Minnesota Power
and Light Co. The total breakdown shows 35% of
the frontage is owned by MP&L, 23% is federal
land and 21% is tax-forfeited, 7% is state-
held, 7% is undesignated lakeshore and 7% is
privately held. Included among the 100 "private"
owners are Potlatch Corp, Reserve Mining Co.,
Kimberly Clarke and several other wood pulp
industries.

Quie, on the other hand, pontificates
in the nationally heralded DNR Volunteer,
January-February 1979 issue. "I commend the
many career professionals at the DNR, the
Pollution Control Agency, and other state
agencies which manage and protect our resources
"unfortunately, Quie's "intercession" was a
complete surprise to the DNR Rivers Project
leaders who wre qualifying data on both sides
of the issue in preparation for the February
hearings when the postponement decision went
to press.

The response on the part of lawmakers
is clearly inconsistent; supporting two or
more county boards trying to establish a plan
for the same mile of river is incompatible with
a@ plan of protection. The reaction to a lack
of county revenue from state-owned lands is inaccu-
rate, given the plan's call for continued owner-
ship on the part of landowners. Considering only

7% of the land in question is held by individuals,
Sen. Doug Johnson and Rep. Joe Begich cannot pre-
tend to act in the interest of this region

when sponsoring legislation which is amenable

to MP&L and the other monopolistic concerns at
hand.

The St. Louis County position is most ironic.
Usunty river ownership is clarified in the
St. Louis County Department of Planning and
“oning river corridor plan as 49% MP&L's:
Campbell admits "development outside the 'more
suitable' areas would probably occur if the county
plan is adopted.”

Time expended on this 25-page alternative
plan and the surrounding literature raises a
serious question. Several thousands of county
tax dollars: have been spent on a plan which is
admittedly faulty. This plan, which highlights
MP&L's preponderant ownership and qualifies the
limited amount of privately held shoreline in
St. Louis County further implicates these public
servants acting prudently in the region's behalf.

The issue is simply cut. Landowners fear
control of the river and want to preserve the
Cloquet without monopolistic takeover. Opponents
of the designation deny the preservation
possibilities of the Management Plan. Presently,
MP&L can appreciably reduce the Island Lake
water table or allow the lower stretches of the
Cloquet to "run dry” during the summer months.
Any variance which allows "commercial and indus-
trial development in some areas" could only
foster more situations of this type on the Cloquet.

The Wild and Scenic River designation of the
Cloquet is in the best interests of this region.
The arguments range far beyond the preservation
of this unique eco-system, which is 15 minutes
from Duluth's back door. The rights of those few
who own the 7% of truly privately held land
along the Cloquet River deserve all the protection
this plan will afford.

The credibility of the People's Property
Rights Association is questionable in view of
these statistics. The association's spoke-
person is Norman Poupore, a former MP&L employee.

An MP&L dam controls the water level of the
28.5 mile lower stretch of the Cloquet, and the
shoreline levels of Island Lake. The county plat
maps designate about 6,000 acres of land in the
Alden Lake Basin as "Proposed Thompson Reser-
voir." There is no questioning who is in literal
command of the river at present.

Some of the landowners serving on the Cloquet
Kiver Citizens Advisory Council have supported
the Department of Natural Resources management
plan. ;

Several recent political maneuvers take a new
twist when these facts are weighed against the
timely response of a variety of public servants.

Most notable examples include (1) action on the
part of Gov. Albert Quie to postpone scheduled

. hearings previously and currently required by

legislation of which some of them were involved,
and (3)action on the part of St. Louis County
commissioners to oust the designation with a
county plan which embraces philosophies such as
"the remainder, however, would probably be
zoned for intense development, including some
commercial and industrial uses", as stated by
Thomas Campbell, senior county planner.

Poupore publically praised the decision to
postpone hearings regarding the Cloquet,
stating in the Feb. 3 News-Tribune "I think it
is very good and very fair on their part.

Creees®

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.