August 1980 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown
August 1980 Magazine
Magazine · 8 pages
Search this issue
For the full-resolution original, use Open PDF above. Your browser handles PDF zoom and navigation.
Searchable text for scan page 5
BOUNDARY WATERS CANOE AREA The United States Forest Service, an
It's Political Survival agency of the Department of Agriculture imple-
: : mented a management plan as a result of the
leophold. The BWCA was divided into two zones.
The Interior Zone, where logging is prohibited,
covers 618,000 acres. This zone is where the
by Barbara Ford heaviest recreational use occured. The Portal
The BWCA is.a lake-dotted wilderness Zone, where logging was allowed, comprised the
‘located along the borders of Minnesota remaining 412,000 acres of BWCA.
™, and Canada for 110 miles. The largest . :
continuous block of virgin forest remaining ; The logging industry was satisfied,
in the eastern part of our nation is in its saying that the Portal Zone could be man-
million acre expanse. Some of the world's aged to produce lumber for centuries while
most majestic stands of red pine, some of . the conservationists could enjoy the wilder-
which were seedlings in the 16th century, : ness zone that covered more than half of
and the famous Ely Greenstone, one of the the BWCA.
oldest rocks on earth, are among the trea- : : .
sures to be found there. “-..«But conservationists opposed the
Forest Service action, maintaining that the ©
The 1964 Wilderness Act by Congress Portal zone contains one-third of the virgin
allowed the Canoe Area to become part of the timber in the BWCA. The continued to argue
National Wilderness Preservation System, for the next ten years that the entire BWCA
E which is dedicated to human enjoyment with- was meant by Congress to be wilderness.
a ‘out mechanized- intrusion. This Act con-— Finally, in 1973, the Sierra Club brought
firmed what was a precedent throughout the a suit under the Wilderness Act. Federal
histery of the BWCA since its inclusion District Judge Miles Lord ruled in favor
in the Superior National Forest in 1909. of the Sierra Club by granting a permanent
: injunction against further logging of any
- A new hazard to the preservation of large continuous blocks of virgin forest
natural conditions in the canoe country in the Wilderness area.
appeared in 1925. E.W. Backus, President
of the Minnesota and Ontario Paper Company Later, the Forest Service and the
‘declared he was going to begin large-scale loggers took the case to a federal appeals
logging in the area and planned to build court. On August 30, 1976, the court
a series.of hydro-electric dams in the reversed Judge Lord's injunction. The
chain of lakes along the border. By court stated that Congress had clearly |
flooding. the area it would have made it accorded "special treatment" to the BWCA
easier and cheaper to cut timber. But and wanted the area to be managed ina
after a bitter fight in Congress, a bill : manner that would maintain its primitive
‘was passed that banned logging within 400 character without unnecessarily restrict-
feet of shoreline of any lake in the region. ing logging.
Backus dropped his plan.
Even though-the injunction was over-
In the late 1940's there was another turned, the logging companies agreed to
threat to the region. Bush pilots began a temporary moratorium. In 1976 the
regularly flying fisherman to lakes deep Secretary of Agriculture issued an order
2 inside the forest, encouraging a thriving banning all snowmobiles, which were
eS resort business. Sigurd Olson, 80-year-old originally allowed in as "winterized
author, and others, protested that the BWCA motorboats."
es was becoming polluted, ruined by "those
'™ squads of flying fishermen." In the 94th Congress, there were,
e two major bills regarding the BWCA that
% The government never fully resolved the could have ended the controversy and
dispute between those who wanted to preserve clarified the Canoe Area's status once
the region in its original tate and those who and for all.
want to extract its natural resources. While
the principal intent of the Wilderness Act Congressman Donald Fraser recog-
was to maintain the primitive character of nized the need for more wilderness land
.;lands to be designated as wilderness, Hubert allocations east of the Rockies by pro-
Humphrey, D-Minn., is responsible for a last- tecting the entire one-million acre
minute loophole. Humphrey successfully BWCA. The bill would not allow any
amended the legislation to permit logging and logging, motorized vehicles or mining in
g ' motorboats in’the Canoe Area. Because of that the area.
+ loophole, the people of Minnesota have become
3 divided among themselves in the fight that Congressman James Oberstar's bill
3 e * continues today, even after Congress passed would endorce the 2-zone system, allowing
# a bill spelling out what the wilderness area logging and motorized vehicles in one wy
should be. er ; 5 zone but not the other. Pad
Hage F se
7 * 2 .-
“ar? Serge ee paths ie Savas <a e- ee pe! oer deh Ps 2 a
Article contents & approved summaries (0)
No article summaries are available for this view.