← Back to The HUT

March 1980 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

March 1980 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 12 pages

For the full-resolution original, use Open PDF above. Your browser handles PDF zoom and navigation.

Scan page 3 of March 1980 Magazine
Searchable text for scan page 3

BOUNDARY WATERS CANOE AREA
It's Political Survival

This is the last of the series concerning
the BWCA dispute.

by Barbara Ford

During hearings in the summer of 1977
in Minnesota on the two bills, there was
much shouting and finger pointing. Some
people claimed that making the BWCA a full
wilderness would deplete the local tax
base to.a critical. degree. Resort owners
said they would go bankrupt. Loggers said
they would not have enough softwood if they
were banned from the BWCA.

._ On the other side, a group was formed
called the Friends of the Boundary Waters
Wilderness. Its campaign includes a poster
with a spectacular photograph of ‘canoe
country and two lines of small, white type:
"The Boundary Water Wilderness--Take a
Long. Last Look Before It Vanishes."

The BWCA would vanish in a reletively few
years, too, if the land continued to be
abused. According to Superior National
Forest Studies, the thin, rocky soils of
the BWCA lands are the Forest's

least productive and the most sensitive. If
‘good forestry is practiced on the more fertile
and accessible lands nearer the pulp mills,
Minnesota can grow its present annual cut of
two million cords of forest products on fewer
than eight million acres--all outside of the
BWCA, according to Heinselman.

"The BWCA is not a good place to grow trees
for profit," William Nye, Minnesota Department
of Natural Resources chief, said.

The other issue that was under consideration was
the question of recreational use conflicts--
motorcraft versus paddle canoes and snowmobiles
versus cross-country skiers, Nye said. During
that time, federal law regulation activities

in the Canoe Area permitted the use of motor-
craft on more than 60 percent of the water
surface. Pressure was also heavy from snow-
mobiles in the congressional debates even though
there have been only about 7,000 snowmobiler
visits annually compared to 95,000 visits by
paddlers, hikers, skiers, and snowshoers iin the
BWCA, according to Heinselman.

"Sources of Congestion and Visitor Dissatisfac-
tion in the BWCA," by David Line, Forest
Service geographer, said 93 percent of the
paddlers found their experience impaired by
encounters with motorized vehicles. Minnesota
has 14,000. non-BWCA lakes on which motorboat ing
ig legal. Snowmobilers can legally operate on
those same 14,000 lakes when they are frozen

over, as well as on national and state forest
lands, in many state parks, and on thousands of
miles of state and private trails and along
road rights-of-way. ;

All of the heated debate finally resulted in a
compromise bill which was approved by the House
Sub-committee on Parks in April of 1978. The
proposal was introduced by Reps. Phillip Burton
of California and Burce Vento of Minnesota.

The compromise made a concession to both posi-
tions by allowing for more wilderness protection
yet it opened an additional 15 lakes to motor-
boat use and allowing two snowmobiling
corridors through the BWCA. The bill also con-
tained a provision to require the government to
buy the property of any resort owner who wants
to sell but would change their operations from
motorized recreation to wilderness canoeing,
hiking and the like,

That bill was eventually replaced by one from
Sen. Wendall Anderson of Minnesota. Anderson
had made it clear that he did not support a

bill sponsored by Fraser that would make the
BWCA free from logging, mining, motorboats and
snowmobiles.

But, it seemed as though there was more at stake
than just a wildernesss designation for the
Canoe Area. Rep. Fraser and Sen. Anderson were
both looking at a seat in the Senate. Election
results showed a definite north-south split among
Minnestoa voters, causing Fraser to lose by a
narrow margin. It seemed as though voters were
judging him by his strong pro-wilderness stand.

Anderson may have lost the election because
of his political goals and how he tried to
achieve them instead of his views on the
BWCA. His bill was too much of a compri-
mise, and a more acceptable one at that,

to hurt him politically. His ambitions
seemed to become more evident during one

of his fund-raising events in St. Paul.

John Denver, singer and active member of
environmentalist group, Friends of the

Earth, performed in the Twin Cities in

April of 1978 at a fund raiser for Anderson's
Senate election campaign. They have known
each other for two years, and their coopera-
tion was never noticed until two weeks

before that when Anderson: made public his
intentions for the BWCA. At least 160 of

the 17,000 ticketholders reportedly asked

for refunds in protest to Anderson's position.

Even though the issue of the BWCA Wilderness
was supposedly settled, a suit seeking invali-
dation of the 1978 BWCA legislation was filed
in U.S. District Court in Washington. In

July of 1979 the Citizens Committee on the
BWCA, composed of nine northeastern Minnesota
residents and eight from the rest of the state

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.