← Back to The HUT

October 1980 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

October 1980 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 16 pages

October 1980 Magazine

Captured text — scan page 11

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

CLIFFS
CORNER

by Cliff Jacobson

manufacturers' claims, glass poles don't hold up.
They splinter and break. The solid ones are too
heavy and snap when stressed; the hollow ones:
simply splinter and deform badly.

4. Dome tents (geodesic domes not included) won't
make it in high winds. Even well guyed domes
erush badly when the wind blows. Ask Bob
Dannert about the 6-foot high rock wall he built

There's a misconception among canoeists and back- around his fully guyed JanSport dome on the Back
packers alike that you "get exactly what you pay for" River so it wouldn't be flattened by a polar gale!
when you buy outdoor gear. For some items, like ;

canoes, paddles, pack stoves, and most types of 5. Geodesic domes are fine for winter or when
hardware, that's usually true enough. But for a lot of you've got time to set them up. But they're hard
software—summer weight sleeping bags, foam pads, to erect in the dark; most are badly vented; and
clothing, and the like—there's a point of diminishing they lack a protected awning for dry entry/exit.
returns—a place where more dollars spent simply They're not good canoe tents even though they're
means fancier tailoring and better detailing, but no great for the mountains.

improvement in function.
6. Open tents (Baker styles) are very comfortable

The “law of diminishing returns" comes earlier for when pitched out of the wind. These tents go up
canoe tents than for backpacking tents (the two are slow and blow down easily. They're good "forest"
not necessarily the same). For example, backpackers tents, but lack privacy.

are concerned with extremely light weight, often at
the expense of other variables. And for trips above

_timberline, wind stability is essential. In_ short, So back to basics. The most wind-stable designs are
backpacking tents incorporate extra reinforcement, old-fashioned A-frames and Indian teepees. However,
tighter stitching, terisioning devices, low aerodynamic teepees (like the Sierra Design hex tent) have too
profile, and more to achieve these aims. The result many stakes to set, and their flies are a mess to keep
to the consumer is high cost. Very high cost! taut. So best choice for canoeing is the A-frame.
My favorite tents? I like the Cannondale tents best

But canoe tents are different. Winds of over 50 mph and consider them a cut above all others, regardless
are rare in the canoe country. And the canoeist can of price. Cannondales are the fastest to pitch in any
afford to carry a "bit more" weight and bulk than. the weather as they have but four stakes, two poles, and
backpacker. The difference between two roughly an integral attached fly. They'll easily take-70 mph
equivalent performing tents—one that weighs eight winds with barely a murmur and remain dry in a near

pounds, the other ten—may be hundreds of dollars. hurricane. Cost? $250-$325 and really worth it.
Two pounds is meaningless for most types of canoe
tripping. Prime considerations for a good canoe tent I'd rate best tent for the money—indeed best for
are spaciousness (try keeping your sanity in a five by under $250—the "Eureka Timberline" (or comparable
seven doghouse when black flies or foul weather models designed around this configuration). Granted,
forees you to stay put), reasonable headroom for ease construction isn't first rate, but design is. And
of dressing, and absolute bugproofing. Include also design is what keeps you dry in a downpour and safe
extreme resistance to the often gargantuan downpours in a__ wind. Frankly, every other tent I've seen
that are typical of much of the north country. To (including some that cost nearly $500) take a back
this add ease and speed of pitching (minimal staking seat to these and the Cannondales.
so the tent can be set up on the near solid rock of :

the Canadian Shield), excellent venting .(so you won't The Cannondales come with one or two _ built-in
baste in your own juices on those 90-degree nights), - vestibules (depending on model). The vestibules—a
and a weather-protected entry. (If you've every place to store wet boots and gear, plus an effective
climbed into a dome tent sans tunnel entrance in a way to wind and waterproof the vulnerable front end
major downpour, you know what I mean.) of any tent—is a $40 or so extra cost option on the
Eureka. Once you've used a vestibule, you'll never

Years ago, I did the research and evaluation on 2-man trip without one. Vestibules provide the edge that

tents for a BACKPACKER Magazine project. I looked spells success under really rugged conditions.
at about 50 different tents that ranged in cost from

about 50 bucks to "I'm embarrassed to tell you." What about single-walled Gore-tex tents? Well...the
Here are some of my discoveries: jury is still out as to how well Gore-tex Il works. My

own experiments indicate it's a considerable
improvement over Gore-tex I. But, frankly, I think
you'll dislike any single-walled tent, even a breathable
Gore-tex one. Why? Simply because the overlapping
space between fly and inner tent at ground level
provides room to set wet boots and oddities. If you
don't have a vestibule, you don't want to drag wet
boots into your tent. I commonly place my boots
: between tent wall and fly in non-vestibule equipped
rough weather performance is GOOD DESIGN, tents. Also, the true ——— in weight (oor tax
which, as mentioned, has nothing to do with versus double-walled nylon) between the tents is less
quality of construction. than you think. But the cost is sky high, and the foul
weather reliability of Gore-tex hasn't been established.

1. High cost does not necessarily indicate good
design. It only indicates quality construction and
detailing.

2. There's no relationship between tightness of
stitching or "number of stitches per inch" and
wind stability. The variable that determines good

I've never seen a tent come apart at the seams in
a good blow, but I've seen lots of badly design,

well constructed tents destruct due to pole Tips: Shock-cord all your poles (kits are available at
failure or torn fabric resultant from improper eamp shops) and attach loops of shock-cord to all guy
tensioning or poor aerodynamic shape. and stake lines. So rigged, a tent will withstand

quite a blow. My old Gerry "fireside" rigs with a
3. I've never seen a. tent with fiberglass poles that single I-pole at each end and has stood up in a near
was worth a damn in a_e wind. Despite 1 1 hurricane outfitted this way. When a gale comes, run

Cont. on Pg. 15

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.