← Back to The HUT

September 1981 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

September 1981 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 16 pages

For the full-resolution original, use Open PDF above. Your browser handles PDF zoom and navigation.

Scan page 6 of September 1981 Magazine
Searchable text for scan page 6

TAXING RACING CANOES TO RAISE FISH According to Canoe magazine and the Minneapolis
Tribune's Ron Schara, many fishermen feel that non-

by Chuck Holst fishing boaters have been getting a free ride for the
last 30 years. The gist of the argument is that non-
How would you like to pay an extra $10 to $30 on fishing boaters, including canoeists, have been using
your next We-no-nah or Sawyer canoe in order to fishermen-funded access sites and facilities without in
help support sport fishing in America? That would be any way contributing themselves.
the effect of a bill before Congress to expand the
Dingell-Johnson Fish Restoration Act of 1950. The This seems reasonable until you start looking closely
Dingell-Johnson Act was designed to aid the states in at the facts. A call to the Minnesota DNR's Division
improving fisheries management, purchasing and of Fish and Wildlife informed me that : 1) the bulk
improving fishing accesses, and in other ways of the D-J funds received by Minnesota goes to fish
enhancing the sport fishing environment by providing management, so only a small amount is spent on access
matching federal funds to the states. sites; and 2) access sites are chosen primarily on the
basis of fishing potential—other recreational
Funding for this program is provided by an indirect considerations are ignored. (I hope to have more
tax on the fishermen who benefit from it. This takes precise information in the next issue of HUT!.)
the form of a 10% federal sales tax on sport fishing Obviously, only a very small part of our contribution
equipment and accessories such as rods, reels, lures, as canoeists would benefit us in any way.
creels, tackle boxes, and so forth. The tax is
imposed on the manufacturer or importer, so the Also, all the fishing accesses I have seen are designed
typical sportsman is rarely aware of it, but you can for trailer access, except on rivers like the Brule
bet your bentshaft he pays it in the end. Not that are not navigable by fishing boats. Canoes do
unjustly, either, for it is a good program. In fact, not require ramps any more than kayaks do. Yet
the American League of Anglers is one of the Act's boats that do require ramps—hydroplanes and
staunchest supporters. sailboats—are specifically exempted from the proposed
tax (though their trailers are not). So the access
However, the original act unaccountably left out some argument fails on its logic. If use of fishing accesses
basie fishing equipment, such as fishhooks, and failed were a significant concern, all trailerable boats would
to provide for newer developments, such as electronic be taxed. Plainly, this is not a concern of the bill;
fish finders. So a new bill is before Congress to by its internal logic, canoes are to be taxed only
provide additional funds for the D-J program by because they can be used as fishing platforms.
taxing these neglected items. Unfortunately, along
the way someone decided that canoes were just as My basie point is that (to quote Canoe magazine)
much fishing accessories as rod belts and fishing "fishermen fish; paddlers paddle." Those paddlers who
chairs. Title I of the Fish Restoration Act of 1981 fish have already paid their dues; the rest of us
(H.R. 2250 and S. 546, also known as_ the should not have to. The eanoe is a form of
Dingell-Johnson Expansion Act) would impose a 3% transportation, not a fishing accessory. It makes just
value-added tax on "boats not more than 25 feet in as little sense to tax canoes as fishing accessories as
length except hydroplanes, kayaks, and sailboats." it would to tax snowshoes as ice fishing accessories.
There is no mention of canoes as such, but they are (By the way, ice augers and ice houses are included
not specifically exempted as kayaks are. I assume in the bill.) —=
that decked canoes would also be taxed despite their
resemblance to kayaks. If you agree with me that canoes should be exempted
from the Fish Restoration Act of 1981, you can help
The unfairness of this bill is obvious. It assumes that by writing your congressman and senators:
canoes are used primarily, if not exclusively, for
fishing, that they are nothing more than large, House
expensive fishing accessories. I am talking about ~—~“The Honorable
Grummans, USCA cruisers, pro boats, Olympic racers, House of Representatives
decked canoes, whitewater canoes, sailing canoes— Washington, D.C. 20515
anything called a canoe, whatever its form or
function. The bill does not recognize canoeing as a Senate
sport in its own right. The Honorable
United States Senate
MCA members who have their own canoes, however, Washington, D.C. 20510
own them because they enjoy paddling, or because
canoes give them mobility in a way compatible with Briefly express your opposition to H.R. 2250 and S.
wilderness. Many fish, but of those who do, most do 546 in their present forms, stating that: 1) canoes
so infrequently, more as an afterthought than as a are not fishing equipment and therefore should be
goal. I pack a camera and a light meter on my exempt from any tax that supports sport fishing, and
BWCA trips in the same way many people pack fishing 2) only equipment specifically designed for fishing
equipment, but I would never seriously think of my should be taxed, not multi-purpose forms of
eanoe as a photographic accessory. transportation. Be as concise as possible. Be sure
also to send a copy of your letter to Rep. John
The MCA is a special group; other canoeists fish Breaux, Chairman, Subcommittee on Fisheries and
more. But even among the general public, canoes are Wildlife Conservation and the Environment, H2-544
used more for general recreation than for fishing. A House Annex II, Washington, D.C. 20515. Rep.
look at the St. Croix River or the Minneapolis lakes Breaux introduced the bill.
on a summer weekend should be enough to convince
anyone of that fact. Most fishermen prefer fishing Cont. on Pg. 15

boats to canoes (except for special places such as the
-BWCA). If a fishing resort furnishes both fishing

boats and canoes to its guests, you can be sure the
latter will be used only for paddling around. | Te) |
AS _ _ 2

There is another side to the argument, of course. 6 101 - 79th Avenue North / Minneapolis, Minnesota 55444

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.