← Back to The HUT

November 1981 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

November 1981 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 16 pages

November 1981 Magazine

Captured text — scan page 11

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

from the Wilderness Society As Vice Chairman of the Federal Power Commission
(September 1975-June 1977), Watt helped triple prices

The Wilderness Society announces the immediate on "new" natural gas from 50 cents to $1.42 per
formation of "Wilderness Watch," a special task force thousand cubic fet.
devoted to the day-to-day monitoring of the vital
policies, decisions, and actions that affect our public As President and Chief Legal Officer for the
land and wild lands made by James Watt, the United Mountain States Legal Foundation (June 1977-January
States Secretary of the Interior. His qualifications to 1981), Watt's leadership gave the organization the
protect our environment... reputation of being anti-consumer, anti-feminist,
anti-black, anti-government, and, above all,
As a lobbyist for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce anti-environmentalist. For example, Watt said the
(September 1966-January 1969), Watt lobbied against Departments of Agriculture and Interior cannot claim
Senator Edmund Muskie's attempts to draft the nation's the delegated power they have from Congress to
principal water quality legislation. restrict public access to federally owned lands—in

giving them wilderness protection, for instance.
As Deputy Assistant Interior Secretary (May 1969-June

1972), Watt awarded two consulting contracts totaling It is not enough just to be frightened by the

$60,000 to a friend. He later admitted to a Senate disastrous policies James Watt can inflict on our land,

committee that he had made a serious error and had to our natural wilderness heritage.

violated his own standards, but "when you're trying to

get results, you go to people you know." Each of his policies, decisions, recommendations, and
actions must be carefully monitored and their impact

As Director of the Bureau of Recreation (July on our wilderness studied. And whenever Secretary

1972-September 1975), Watt took a tour of a remote Watt sets forth on a path that will permanently

mountain region within a state park system and asked damage our wilderness and wildlife, someone must

his escort why the large stands of ripe timber weren't blow the whistle!

being harvested and why the thick meadows weren't

being grazed. Watt's host remembers, "I got the The Wilderness Society and its new "Wilderness

feeling he didn't understand the purpose of parks." Watch" is prepared to do just that.

1978 BWCA ACT UPHELD

(Taken from FRIENDS OF THE BOUNDARY WATERS In addition, the Court held that the 1978 Act does
WILDERNESS, October 1981) not infringe on any so-called state's rights. The
opinion states that the restrictions on use of
We have good news to report: The United States motorboats and snowmobiles regulate only private
Court of Appeals has upheld the 1978 Boundary conduct, and not the state itself. On July 24, 1980,
Waters Canoe Area Wilderness legislation! U.S. District Judge Miles Lord called his decision a
victory for both sides. Judge Lord wrote, "The only
On September 30, 1981, the U.S. Court of Appeals for extent to which the state's jurisdiction is restricted
the 8th Circuit in St. Louis, Missouri, agreed with an by the act concerns the situation where Minnesota
earlier decision by U.S. District Judge Miles W. Lord would wish to open more surface water for motorized
that Congress has the power to limit use of traffic. Nothing in the Act. divests the state of its
motorboats and snowmobiles inside the Boundary authority to regulate mining in the BWCA."

Waters Canoe Area.
It remains to be seen whether the state or the other

The Court upheld the 1978 Act on all counts, deciding appellants will file a petition for review with the
against the State of Minnesota and the two associated United States Supreme Court. If they do, it would
eases brought by the National Association of Property take an affirmative vote of four justices in order for
Owners (NAPO) and some northeastern Minnesota the Court to hear the case. We expect that a
groups. All three judges who heard the appeal petition will be filed at least by the National
eoneurred in the ruling. The Court's opinion is a Association of Property Owners (a right-wing group
sweeping victory for the BWCA, and should become a headquartered in San Antonio, Texas). State officials,
nationwide precedent in wilderness cases. under the direction of Governor Al Quie, are

reportedly considering an appeal.
On June 18, 1981, State of Minnesota attorneys argued

before the Court of Appeals that the state alone owns Minnesota DNR Commissioner Joe Alexander claims
and controls the lakes in the BWCA, and that the that he and the governor are worried "that the way
federal government cannot extend its regulations has been cleared for somebody to exploit the area's
beyond its own land. The Court disagreed. "We minerals" and that an appeal may be necessary to save
reject this contention and conclude that Congress, in the BWCA from exploitation. There is substantial
passing this legislation, acted within its authority evidence, however, that Governor Quie's true interest
under the property clause of the United States in the legal battle is to almost double the water area
Constitution..." ; open to motorboats and snowmobiles. The state filed

its suit in January 1979, before the election of Ronald
The Court ruled that Congress passed the Act with Reagan and James Watt—and against the advice of
the clear intent of insuring that the BWCA would Minnesota Attorney General Warren Spannaus.
remain as wilderness; that Congress concluded that Because the state has already spent over $100,000 to
motorized vehicles "significantly" interfere with the date in outside attorney fees (not to protect the
use of the wilderness by canoeists, hikers, and skiers; BWCA but to garner votes in northeastern Minnesota)
and that restricted motorized use would enhance and the Friends of the Boundary Waters Wilderness
preserve the wilderness values of the area. Congress coalition is preparing for the worst. Thank you,
therefore was within its power in enacting regulations members, for your continued financial and moral
to protect the federal wilderness lands. TI support.

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.