December 1981 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown
December 1981 Magazine
Magazine · 12 pages
Search this issue
For the full-resolution original, use Open PDF above. Your browser handles PDF zoom and navigation.
Searchable text for scan page 4
ACT NOW... AND WRITE IN Specifically, ask him to recommend the following
existing standards to be enforced not later than
AGENCY HEAD SELLS OUT TO 3M December 31, 1982. Write to: Mr. Howard Kaibel,
AND KOCH REFINERY Jr., 1745 University Avenue, St. Paul, Minnesota
55104. Thanks for your help!
80 Percent of Northern Lakes Acidifying as Air
Quality Standards are Further Weakened Sulfur Health Environment
Dioxide Primary Secondary
(Taken from December 1981 BWCA Wilderness News)
Annual
In June 1981, the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency average -02 ppm -02 ppm
(MPCA) announced that 80 percent of our northern 24-hour
lakes are losing their ability to buffer acid rain and average .10 ppm -10 ppm
snow ("some are just sitting ducks"). Ironically, on 3-hour
October 30, 1981, Lou Breimhurst, director of the average .35 ppm .35 ppm
MPCA, in a _ little-publicized letter to hearing
examiner Howard Kaibel, recommended a further (and Ozone -
substantial) weakening of Minnesota's once-protective ppm = parts per million
air quality standards. 1-hour
average .07 ppm .07 ppm
We have learned that Bob Johnson, an executive with ~
3M, one of the state's largest air polluters, and
Robert Burk, attorney for the Minnesota Association
of Commerce and Industry (MACI), met privately with
both Governor Al Quie and Director Lou Breimhurst
in the days just preceding Breimhurst's letter of
October 30. The air quality staff of MPCA was not
in agreement with Breimhurst and was surprised by
the timing of the "4th floor decision."
LAST PADDLE, FIRST SKI
by George Skinner
Minnesota's rapidly changing seasons recently provided
me with an opportunity to spend two consecutive
weekends with Lora Lakin and John Wexler. The first
was my only attempt at kayaking this year. The next
week found us cross country skiing at Baker Park.
Both were spur of the moment trips. Our goal was to
have some laughs.
The agency staff had previously recommended a more
protective set of standards for both ozone (smog) and
sulfur dioxide (acid rain precursor). Although the
Friends were disappointed with the original June 1981
recommendation, this almost wholesale rollback to less
protective federal standards is completely
We thought John would be providing the laughs on the
first trip. We planned to go down the south fork of
unacceptable. Minnesota's pristine wilderness and its the Crow River from Mayer to Watertown. He kept
three most important industries—agriculture, forestry, ealling our homes to say he hadn't even left
and tourism—depend on clean air. To allow greater Minneapolis yet. Well, we had finally gotten together
concentrations of ozone and sulfur dioxide into the when, as Lora was unlocking her canoe, we heard
atmosphere is an inappropriate tradeoff for 3M's and John say, "You know, you don't really need to lock
Koch Refinery's short term gain. that up." That comment from John (Hey, they're
gone!) Wexler really broke us up.
In addition, Breimhurst's revision goes against the
recommendations made by Minnesota's departments of We were so out of it that neither Lora nor I stopped
health and natural resources—and totally ignores the to think before trying the cheese John was handing
letters and testimony of hundreds of citizens and out. I had not remembered my vow--NEVER EAT
scientific experts. Finally, the revision is contrary to ANYTHING Wexler hands out—not until the full horror
Breimhurst's own support of the original staff of that foul chunk reached my brain.
recommendation, dated June 1981, in which he wrote:
"We have responded to the testimony and exhibits and The only thing that stunk more than that cheese was
views of those who have participated in the my kayak paddling ability. I proved to be the real
hearing...and believe that the judgements and clown of the trip. I spun, splashed, skidded, and
conclusions we have made are reasonable ones." bumped my way downriver. No matter how I tried, I
just couldn't keep up with those sometime racers.
The MPCA staff has conducted itself in a fair and After being informed that they were just drifting with
impartial manner. The same can be said for the the current, I accepted the repeated offer of a tow.
hearing examiner, Howard Kaibel. We appreciate the We found that I couldn't keep the kayak behind the
complexity of this long, difficult hearing and the eanoe, so I transferred to it. Nightfall found us far
manner in which the hearing has been conducted. On from Watertown. We took out under a bridge. Lora
the other hand, we find the personal attacks against and John walked back to the car. Seems we were
the agency staff and the hearing examiner by industry still in Mayer.
representatives and utility spokesmen (NSP)
reprehensible. These individuals have repeatedly Needless to say, I was real happy when they called
delayed and obstructed the hearing process with the next weekend and invited me to go skiing.
innuendo, petty allegation, and dissembling behavior. Actually, John wanted to borrow my poles. But
service as club president must soften the heart, so I
Industry's most recent effort to gain another delay was invited. Baker was nice, except where the trails
(meanwhile Minnesota's current standards have been were flattened into a 5-foot wide sheet of glaze by
suspended) has apparently been successful, and the the grooming machine. But even that couldn't mar the
hearing record will now remain open at least through beauty of skiing through snow-covered woods. I just
the end of the year. We do not expect final oral couldn't believe the contrast in the seasons and my
arguments until February, nor a decision until April. luck as compared to one week earlier. I didn't fall
This is a critical time to write to Howard Kaibel, on anything!
even if you have written to him already. Urge him
to resist industry pressure--and to reject Breimhurst's John and Lora must have been thinking of our last
weakening revision. Ask him to bring this hearing to a weekend, though. They kept demonstrating Eskimo
a close! rolls.
Article contents & approved summaries (0)
No article summaries are available for this view.