← Back to The HUT

December 1981 · Volume/issue not printed or unknown

December 1981 Magazine

Issue first-page cover

Magazine · 16 pages

December 1981 Magazine

Captured text — scan page 12

Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.

a ; : mechanical jet-cleaning device and was a bit lighter
CLIFF'S Ka Bee 1 Deh dace and more reliable than the new self-cleaning 123U. If

: Gib you have an old 123 (or upright 71 Primus), be sure

a A YA you remove the jet screw on the barrel of the burner
before you clean the stove with the little wire
provided. Don't force the wire down the hole in the
jet--you'll just push carbon into the barrel of the
stove. ,

These little stoves have a wick much like that in a
Zippo lighter, so don't overprime them with too much
gasoline. If you’get the wick too hot, you'll scorch it
and the stove won't run right again. And putting in a
new wick, isn't all that easy. Best way to use the
Svea 123 is with the Optimus cook kit, that's especially
designed for it.

by Cliff Jacobson

This month I. promised you the lowdown on trail
stoves—a no punches pulled assessment of what works
and what doesn't. First, some background. Over the
past 10 years, I've used just about every camp stove
made-—not for a few minutes or hours, but for days or
weeks. I've put on dozens of "stove" workshops for
the DNR and had at my disposal every trail stove in
production. So what you'll read here is first-hand
experience, not some magazine evaluation.

OPTIMUS 111B

I've never used a stove that will take the abuse of
the 111B. It's the stove for the serious canoe

GASOLINE STOVES: These are very reliable and expeditioner. This stove will never let you down!
relatively clean burning. They have the highest heat Drop it off a cliff (I've done it), submerge it in
output of any stoves. Drawbacks? Gas is explosive water, put it right out in the wind, give it to a bunch
and more dangerous to use than other fuels. of teenagers, and it'll run and run and run. And

Nevertheless, its performance in bad weather is vastly there's nothing to break—no dials or wires or exposed
superior to other fuel types. parts. Drawbacks? It's really expensive—about 80

dollars. But it will outlast three 35 dollar stoves.
KEROSENE STOVES: About the same BTU output as ,

gas, but less volatile. Where a gas stove will COLEMAN PEAK I
explode, a kerosene one will burn. But kerosene
stoves don't start unless they're primed with alcohol This is a decent little stove at a good price which
or gasoline—a disadvantage. has received high ratings. It's hot and it runs quiet.
But it's not as good as the literature suggests. The
BUTANE STOVES: Popular because they don't have to stove has some serious problems for expedition use,
be primed or pumped. Good for high altitude use, but including: 1) Too many wires, plastic knobs, etc. that
unsuitable for much else. Their efficiency varies can break or burn off. 2) Even with the fold-out
inversely with the temperature. They won't run at all legs, it's not very stable. 3) Fill the stove too full
when the temperature drops below freezing. When and it leaks gas—and flame—all over the place. 4)
they do run, they're much less efficient than gas or It's supposed to start easy—needs no priming. Don't
kerosene stoves. you believe it! Try cranking one of these stoves in
zero temperatures some time. You'll pump it until
ALCOHOL AND STERNO: Okay for a soldier who . + your thumb turns blue! Even in warm weather you'll
wants to warm a can of beans in a trench between pump it plenty.

battles, but worthless for much else. .

; Advertised boiling times for the Coleman are

If you're serious about canoe camping, you'll get a meaningless. Three of its four quadrants protected by

gasoline or kerosene stove. Other fuels don't cut it! a unique X-shaped windscreen blow out, .which
. quadruples boiling times.

There are four major stove manufacturers: In Europe

there's Optimus and Phoebus; in the U.S. it's Coleman MSR (Mountain Safety Research)
and MSR. Here's an analysis of the most popular
gasoline stoves. The MSR is a fine little stove for winter and
: expedition mountaineering, but it's a bad choice for
OPTIMUS 8R and SVEA 123U eanoeing. Here's why. There are parts which can
; break, bend, or be lost. The windscreen—a piece of
Both are made by Optimus and have been field-proven. heavy aluminum foil--won't accept the handle of a
They're excellent, though cranky, to use. You've got ' frying pan, so you'll have to find a better way to
to prime these stoves with an eyedropper full of gas cook eggs in a wind. The stove won't throttle down
to get them to start, and you need a good windshield. to a simmer—you've got to perch a tin-can lid on top
Otherwise, they work fine. The Svea is the hotter of to dissipate heat so you can fry pancakes. And the
the two stoves, primarily because its fuel tank is cleaning needle is not an integral part of the stove.
located below the cooking pot and is warmed from You've got to disassemble the unit to clean out the
above. The Svea is also easier to start because you carbon. Nevertheless, I like the MSR. It's by far the
can hold a candle under its capped fuel tank to warm hottest of all the gasoline stoves, and it starts the
it; or hold the tank over a secondary heat source fastest. But it's not very versatile.
(another stove) for a few seconds; or warm the tank
by cupping it~in your hands for a half minute (a real PHOEBUS 625
pain!) ete. But the Svea is a tippy little brute—you'll
spill a lot of soup on this stove until you get used to These are no longer imported, but copies are being
it! , ; made and sold under the Phoenix trade name (Precise
Imports, Inc.) These stoves run very hot and quiet
You can get a "mini-pump" for the Optimus stoves, but and have pumps. They're cranky and require lots of
it's a waste of money; the pump won't do anything an tools and gaskets to keep them running. In the long
eyedropper full of gas won't do. run, they're more trouble-free than the Peak I or

MSR. They always start and run well, and they have
Of the two stoves, I prefer the Svea, despite its 12 a good windscreen. If you can get a good buy on
tippiness. The older 123 model didn't have a one, get it!

Article contents & approved summaries (0)

No article summaries are available for this view.