Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.
Would Jobs and |
industry be hurt
by a logging ban’
The BWCA from 1965-72 (previous to the ban) produced
about 3% of the State’s pulpwood and less than 10% of its
softwood. Since the court-imposed ban of 1973 has been in
effect, there has been no claim that mill production has
been diminished, or that loggers have been unemployed as
a result. Prior to’ the 1973 ban, logging in the BWCA
supported about 40 jobs for about five months-of the year
(a few sales allowed summer logging). The economic
health of the Iron Range is improving, as four new taconite
operations are in the process of commencing. Studies by
W.D. Brackel of the University of Minnesota, College of
Forestry, indicate that the “degree to which mining domi-
nates the region’s economy borders on the astounding.”
The Environmental Impact Statement prepared by the For-
est Service states that of the “three t’s, taconite, timber,
.and tourism, taconite overwhelms all the others,” The
economic health of the area depends on iron mining, not
logging.
The Minnesota Forest Resource Task Force, composed
of representatives from industry, the Forest Service, the
Bureau of Indian Affairs, the county land commissioners,
the Governor’s Advisory Counsel, the Iron Range
-Resources and Rehabilitation Commission, the University
of Minnesota College of Forestry and the Minnesota
Departments of Natural Resources and Economic Develop-
ment, prepared a revision of the allowable cut for Minne-
sota in January 1973. Based on these. figures for the
common species of the BWCA, the allowable cut exceeds
that which is actually cut in Minnesota. If the timber
companies will develop lands outside the BWCA for the
harvest of timber, and practice good forestry, sufficient
supplies will continue to exist as they do at present.
The real problem is a deplorably low level of forestry on
most land in Minnesota, and a tendency by industry to
delay investments in forestry and in pulping process
changes until the last high quality natural stands of soft-
woods (pine and spruce). have been cut. In Michigan and
Wisconsin the industry has already depleted its sources of
pine and spruce and has converted its pulp mills to use
aspen, birch, hardwoods, fir, and other abundant species.
Minnesota has -vast untapped supplies of these common
species outside the BWCA. The industry in Minnesota is.
dragging its heels and begging time at the expense of an
irreplaceable natural resource.
10 Wi.
Is BWCA logging -
arevenue source?
U.S. District Judge Miles Lord found in his 1973 decision
that the Forest Service had been subsidizing the timber
industry in the BWCA. The cost that was charged to the
industry was far below that which the Forest Service was
spending per acre to regenerate and manage the land. It.
was the American people who had been paying the indus-
_ try to log the wilderness!
a 2
Ron Winch Photo — Naturalist Magazine.
Nature has provided browse for moose through natural changes in
vegetation for 10,000 years — logging is not needed for wildlife in
Wilderness. -