Automatically captured text may contain recognition errors. Compare it with the original scan.
Why not log if if fire is nature's
the trees will way, why not log
die anyway? === and then burn?
It is true that you cannot literally “preserve” a tree, forest, Logging followed by fire has far different ecological
or even a whole stand of trees of one particular age class. effects from fire in the natural standing virgin forest. For
But the goal of wilderness preservation is not to literally example, if red pine, white pine, jack pine or black spruce
“save’’ individual trees, but rather to maintain and restore’ are cut for timber first, when the slash-covered land is
complete natural ecosystems — the dynamic mosaic of burned over their seeds are destroyed, and it is then
plant communities, wildlife habitats, and animal popula- necessary to artificially re-seed or re-plant if these trees are
tions of a natural region. In the BWCA, fire was the key _ to be regenerated. If this is not done, the area will be taken
environmental factor in the primeval ecosystem that main- over by aspen and birch. In nature, jack pine and black
tained the diversity of vegetation and animal populations, spruce seeds are stored in closed or semi-closed cones
regenerated old forests, recycled nutrients and accounted which open and re-seed the area after the fire’s heat has
for the long term stability of the system. This was also true unsealed their resin coating. Red and white pine are very
of the ecosystems of most of our best-known western fire resistant, and ‘seed-trees’’ usually escape the fire to
Wilderness Areas and National Parks. Modern wilderness regenerate their kind. When a stand is burned after log- |
and park management programs are developing methods — ging, the nutrients. in the mature trees, which would have
to restore fire to its natural role in such areas. Logging been recycled by fire, are lost to the system in the timber
mature forests is not a solution. It will only create a badly _ that is carted off. In addition, herbicides have often been
manipulated and disturbed ecosystem. In the BWCA, the used in the BWCA after seeding or planting to kill the
replacement of conifer forests by aspen and birch and the deciduous trees which quickly grow up and shade the
labyrinth of old logging roads are graphic demonstrations Planted pine. The herbicide used is a combination of 2-4-D
of how human manipulation creates change in the ecosys- and 2-4-5-T, herbicides found to cause birth defects. If we
tem. The ecological principles are the same in the BWCA __ use logging before fire to manage the BWCA, there is no
as in Yellowstone, Glacier, or Sequoia National Parks or Way all the interactions of the natural ecosystem can be
the Bob Marshall and Selway-Bitterroot Wilderness Areas. duplicated. Although this type of forestry is proper in a
If we must log the BWCA to “save” its forests as the timber | ™anaged forest or “tree farm” it is clearly out of place in a
industry claims, then we must also log Yellowstone, Wilderness.
Sequoia, and all the rest! The proof that the virgin forests
and wildlife of the BWCA can persist without logging is
that they are still there after 10,000 years of natural
development.
>
«
by
a
U.S.F.S. Photo — Raymond Naddy Naturalist Magazine
Wilderness, properly administered, will provide prey for this magnificent Fire scars on old pines record a history of periodic natural fires that helped
symbol of the northern wilderness. : maintain open areas and food for moose, beaver, grouse and other wildlife.
lj